Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Why are men sabotaging the ‘she deserved the purse’ trend?

Men have been sabotaging women’s pay-it-forward scheme by wrecking baby aisles and taking money intended for young mothers. Is this a clap-back against the unnecessary spectacularisation of generosity or against women experiencing privileges men have excluded themselves from by unequally distributing parental responsibility?

Across the US, women have been hiding money and gift vouchers among baby products in popular supermarkets as part of a new pay-it-forward scheme developed recently by TikTok users seeking to build a supportive community for mothers struggling to make ends meet.

Dubbed the ‘she deserved the purse trend,’ it began when 28-year-old Danaesha Gonzalez saw a purse abandoned between bottles of lotion and children’s medication while shopping.

Realising it must have been left by a mother forced to choose between what she wanted for herself and what she needed for her child, Gonzalez posted a video – now viewed over 4.6m times – with the caption ‘to the mothers who choose themselves last, you deserve the world tonight and always.’

On the back of this, women on TikTok have since filmed themselves leaving money, gift vouchers, and kind notes in lids of formula or tucked into diaper boxes for unsuspecting parents to find.

Despite the evident humanity that underscores this trend and the fact it’s encouraging individuals to feel culpable for the failings of the state, however, as is often the case it’s received backlash online.

@ginevraskin no hate to anyone who participated in it with good intentions✨🎀💗 #shedeservedthepurse #foryou #fyp #storytime @Rare Beauty @Huda Beauty @Charlotte Tilbury @elfcosmetics #blowthisup #viral ♬ original sound – Ginevra 💌

Many are arguing that although the idea behind it is inherently positive, it gives people an excuse to trash supermarkets in search of the gifts that are concealed there.

With this in mind, content creator Ginevraskin is urging people to carry out their good deeds offline, commenting on the detrimental ‘spectacularisation of philanthropy’ that’s amounted in widespread pandemonium.

She refers to the hordes of people who don’t need the money as much as those it was intended for who have, after watching generous influencers post their good deeds publicly, flocked to supermarkets to destroy baby products as they hunt.

Not only has this meant that parents can’t buy supplies for their children, but it’s also created unnecessary work for low-paid supermarket employees tasked with cleaning up the mess.

Concerningly, a significant majority of the culprits appears to be grown adult men who believe that because they aren’t directly involved in the trend, they’re being excluded.

@dontcrossagayman She deserved the purse, you deserve therapy #target ♬ original sound – Misha

As @dontcrossagayman points out: ‘do they not realise that single dads might exist, and might pick up that formula?’

The irony here is that if male parents are feeling left out, then it’s because they’ve adhered to the unequal distribution of parenting in line with traditional patriarchal gender roles that position women as the primary caregiver.

In other words, either men aren’t considering male parents’ needs at all, or they’re unhappy with the notion that women are being rewarded for doing ‘what they’re supposed to’ (which reflects how deluded they are about family dynamics).

Yet again, men are lashing out at female support systems, rather than doing something constructive and supporting their male peers with whatever issues they may be facing.

This is echoed by the rise in incel culture participation, which men are increasingly turning to in an effort to combat loneliness instead of forming solid social networks with people they can actually talk to and not switch off with.

@just_kate68 #duet with @TRUTH IS WHAT MATTERS #bewrinthewoods #ichoosethebear🐻 #bear #ichoosethebear ♬ original sound – Glolovesbooks2.0

It’s also reminiscent of the man or bear debate, which saw women online choose the wild animal in response to the hypothetical question: ‘if you were alone in the forest, would you rather encounter a bear or a man?’

This outcome was met with confusion and animosity by many men who simply could not comprehend why women would feel safer with a bear when there was a 1 in 12 million chance of being attacked by one in 2022 (compared with a 1 in 6 chance of being attacked by a man).

As @callmebkbk highlights, the question was never supposed to be a debate, but was posed to wake men up to the reality of living as a woman in a world made for – and dominated by – men.

In terms of ‘she deserved the purse,’ it isn’t women alone who deserve the extra help, men do too, but undeniably and overwhelmingly it is women who are most often left to single parent.

The solution, then, is for men to readdress this narrative, to step up where they’re needed, and to not take for granted the generosity of strangers. That, I’m sad to say, is just male privilege.

Accessibility