Celebrities struggle with mental health problems too – but can their public disclosure ever be useful when so many find it hard to truly believe them?
Stigma around mental health struggles is diminishing. Workplaces are starting to take it seriously, discussing the subject more openly, while online spaces are becoming rife with advice on how to cope.
But opening up about depression or anxiety is still inherently difficult. It requires being vulnerable and opening a door to your private mind in a way that other visible health issues may not.
For most, admitting to not being in the best state of mind can be especially hard in moments where, from the outside, everything seems like it should be okay.
So when celebrities, who seem to have the perfect life – their dream job, a polished appearance, and an overflowing bank account – reveal theyβre struggling mentally, why canβt the public empathise even if weβre feeling the pressure ourselves?
Bella Hadid is no stranger to speaking about mental health. Amidst magazine covers, catwalk videos, and luxury holiday snaps, she frequently encourages her social media followers to be mindful, to be kind to themselves and others.
Talking to Vogue a few years ago, Bella admitted that (apart from being diagnosed with chronic Lyme disease since 2012) she regularly feels immense guilt for being depressed, despite being blessed with an βincredible life and having the opportunities [she does].β
Perhaps part of this guilt is due to her awareness that the world is plagued with disparity. Bellaβs Instagram highlights paint her as an empathetic activist, advocating for equal rights and social justice for oppressed communities around the world.
The modelβs latest post, though, has been her most raw to date. It begins with a video interview of Willow Smith discussing feelings of not being good enough, followed by a carousel of images of Bella puffy faced, crying, and hooked up to IV drips.
βThis is pretty much my every day, every night for a few years now,β Bella wrote. The post continues: βSocial media is not real. For anyone struggling, please remember that. Sometimes all youβve gotta hear is that youβre not alone.β
Describing chemical imbalances and mental illness as a non-linear, βflowing rollercoaster of obstaclesβ she also reminds readers that βthere is always a light at the end of the tunnel.β
The response on this post has been mixed. On one end, thereβs been an outpouring of love and support. On the other, people are ambivalent about extending empathy for someone rich, successful, and scientifically proven to be the most beautiful woman in the world.
One sarcastic comment read: βcrying for more attention because she doesnβt get enough alreadyβ. Tough crowd.
Psychologists have tried to understand why we tend to retract empathy for celebrities, admitting that they themselves have been guilty of doing so.
One discerns that maybe some just canβt relate. Or perhaps we think celebrities are simply feeling stressed, rather than experiencing an ongoing, clinical mental disorder. Or maybe, itβs just impossible to imagine that someone with βso much fame and fortuneβ could have a valid reason to ever be that upset.
But with a reported 970 million people suffering from mental health issues globally in 2018 – and that figure climbing rapidly thanks to the pandemic – is it so hard to believe that celebs (who are also human) are included in that number? And are there benefits in accepting this possibility?
Academic research has shown that when stars speak out about mental health, it does help. Thanks to parasocial relationships – where fans feel a sense of closeness to celebrity – audiences may relate to or better understand their own emotions, and become more inclined to address them with a healthcare professional.
After the suicide of the well-loved actor and comedian Robin Williams in 2014, calls placed to Americaβs National Suicide Prevention Hotline increased by 300 percent. When Princess Diana revealed she struggled with bulimia in 1993, the number of women seeking professional help for eating disorders doubled.
Partnered with numerous other examples such as Ariana Grande, Dwayne βThe Rockβ Johnson, and Lady Gaga, researchers concluded that when celebrities open up about mental health issues, the effects on the wider population are largely positive.
Time to think twice
Admittedly, the lives of celebrities are easier than most. They have assistants, personal chefs, trainers, stylists – the list goes on.
But behind the scenes, we canβt really know what anyone is going through. So instead of being quick to judge someone based on what you know about them from the outside, maybe we should take time to think again.
Even in regard to celebrities, itβs important to remember that there arenβt any material possessions – or number of commas in our bank accounts – that can resolve mental health issues permanently. Just ask this guy.
So whether or not you care about celebrities (let alone their take on mental health), itβs worth acknowledging that when anyone with a massive platform sheds light on βtabooβ subject with good intentions, it could help somebody.
Iβm Jessica (She/Her). I’m the Deputy Editor & Content Partnership Manager at Thred. Originally from the island of Bermuda, I specialise in writing about ocean health and marine conservation, but you can also find me delving into pop culture, health and wellness, plus sustainability in the beauty and fashion industries. Follow me on Twitter, LinkedIn and drop me some ideas/feedback via email.
Thereβs a distinct lack of body positivity discourse for male, masc, and non-binary bodies. We need to challenge the attitude that views a specific type of body as more beautiful than another and start to praise all kinds of peaches.
Scrolling on social media, I come across a before and after photo, taken a year apart, of a young woman at the gym. Sheβs about my age and the...
In efforts to cut company emissions and pollution by 2050, the denim brand Levi Strauss & Co. has announced its new climate transition plan detailing its road to net-zero.
Itβs no secret that the fashion industry is now one of the worldβs most unsustainable, with textile waste, pollution, and greenwashing all being unfortunately common practices.
Consumers have become more conscious of how their environmental impact is impacted by their shopping choices,...
Actor Lily Gladstone has called out Valentino, the latest brand to copy Indigenous designers. Protecting these cultural crafts from the capitalist machine is a longstanding βΒ and often exhausting βΒ battle.Β
By now, itβs a familiar cycle: a fashion house unveils its latest collection, the press fawns, social media unearths its problematic roots, and the brand issues a half-hearted statement about inspiration versus appropriation.
This week, it was Valentinoβs turn under the microscope,...
From the 1874 Ugly Girl Papers to the overt normalisation β and promotion β of harmful practices such as preventative botox, are we looking at the end of variety and youth in faces which have all been touched by the same needle?
βThe first requisite in a woman toward pleasing others is that she should be pleased with herself,β begins chapter one of The Ugly Girl Papers;...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok