Coal, oil, and gas are responsible for 86% of human-caused carbon dioxide emissions in the past 10 years. Will these companies be held accountable?
The city of Baltimore recently won a landmark case against some of the world’s biggest oil and gas companies, attempting to hold them accountable for their role in climate change.
The court’s decision is expected to have a substantial ripple effect on similar lawsuits filed by other U.S. cities and states.
Baltimore, a U.S. city located in the coastal state of Maryland, has witnessed the effects of climate change firsthand with increasing sea level, rainfall, and flooding. The city is now facing tens of millions of dollars in costs related to the associated damages as well as threats to public health.
As each summer brings longer and more severe heat waves, the city is required to upgrade housing and provide cooling centers to combat the increased risk of heat stroke and asthma-related hospital visits.
As a result, the city government argues that major fossil fuel companies like British Petroleum (BP), Shell, and Exxon must help pay for the costs of climate change because they misled the public about how their products contribute to global warming.
What role has the fossil fuel industry played in misinformation?
Following an investigation of Exxon’s engagement in climate science by InsideClimate News, it was found that the oil giant knew of climate change as early as 1977, 11 years before it became a public issue.
After years researching the effects of burning fossil fuels on the climate, Exxon helped found and lead the Global Climate Coalition (GCC), an alliance of big-name companies that actively opposed efforts to curb fossil fuel emissions and challenge the science of global warming and climate action. Members of the GCC also included Shell, BP, Chevron, and the United States Chamber of Commerce.
In June 2021, Keith McCoy, ExxonMobil’s now ex-Director of Federal Relations was interviewed by Greenpeace UK’s investigation unit under the impression he was being head hunted for a new job.
When questioned about the company’s role in climate change he stated “Did we aggressively fight against some of the science? Yes […] Did we join some of these shadow groups to work against some of the early efforts? Yes, that’s true”.
In a congressional hearing in October 2021, panelists questioned the CEOs of Shell, BP, ExxonMobil, and Chevron, all of whom denied the companies’ involvement in misleading the public on climate change.
Currently facing backlash from the public, scientists, and politicians at all levels of government across the United States, said companies are now looking at creative ways to solidify their defence in court.
Oil companies on the defence
Before evidence was able to be presented at the Baltimore case, the fossil fuel companies focused their defense on whether such lawsuits can take place in state courts considering climate change is a global issue that is regulated by the federal government.
Karen Sokol, a law professor who studies climate liability cases, argues that such a defense is unreasonable because the allegations against the companies depend on state laws that are meant to protect the public from misleading marketing.
In Maryland and other states like California and Texas, oil companies are also accused of using scare tactics to intimidate activists, courts, and their opponents engaged in similar lawsuits.
This follows claims made by the companies stating that the allegations made against them could threaten the U.S. oil supply.
In Texas, where ExxonMobil is headquartered, the company is fighting off cities in California who are seeking compensation for wildfires, flooding, and other extreme weather events.
In response to these lawsuits, the company has asked the Texas Supreme Court to allow it to use a law that would enable it to take legal action against these city officials. The company argues that in filing lawsuits against ExxonMobil over its role in the climate crisis, said officials are conspiring against the company’s First Amendment rights (the right to free speech).
Over the coming months, numerous rulings in states such as Maryland, California, and Texas, and at the federal level, will dictate the future of big oil in the United States – the world’s second largest greenhouse gas emitting country.
I’m Ghislaine (She/Her), a writer at Thred. I’m a climate activist and Science Communication Lead at ClimateScience and am always happy to talk all things sustainability. Follow me on Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and feel free to drop me some ideas/feedback via email.
One in eight US teenagers under 18 personally know someone who has been targeted with pornographic deepfakes. What is being done about this privacy crisis?
We all know what deepfakes are at this point. Generative AI is adept at accurately capturing a person’s likeness and superimposing it over existing photos or videos. A mere text prompt and a handful of JPEGs are sufficient to do so.
The nefarious potential of the...
The UK government’s emphasis on release over rehabilitation is leading to higher rates of recidivism and making social reintegration impossible. Perhaps it’s time to look to the Spanish system of imprisonment to give young people some kind of chance.
In 2013, the European Court of Human Rights abolished life without parole in its seminal Winter decision on the basis that it violated human rights.
Known as the “right to hope”,...
In South Sudan, a relentless heatwave is forcing the government to shut down schools for the second year in a row, with a temperature as high as 42 degree Celsius posing a real threat.
The South Sudanese government has closed all schools for a period of two weeks after dozens of students collapsed due to extreme heat. The announcement came after reports that an average of 12 students fainted...
A government document won’t change reality. But it has the capacity to endanger lives.
Hunter Schafer, a hugely successful actor whose showreel includes Euphoria, a leading turn in the latest Hunger Games movie, and a stint in the upcoming Blade Runner TV adaption, woke up last week to find herself legally male.
Not in any biological sense, nor in any way that reflected Schafer’s reality, but in the cold, bureaucratic...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok
0 comments
