Close
Search
Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Google’s integrity is brought into question over research bias

By
London, UK
0 comments
0 comments

Google, the ubiquitous search engine we all use for reliable and impartial research, could soon start to oust information on ‘sensitive topics.’ Is this a censorship storm waiting to happen?

Alphabet’s flagship platform Google is under serious fire this week regarding censorship measures, and concern is growing that bias could soon discredit the platform as a reliable search engine.

Sparked by the forced resignation of Dr Timnit Gebru, an AI researcher/scientist at Google, Reuters has since dragged up Google’s legislation imposed last year which stated that papers on sensitive topics would face increasingly stringent vetting before going live.

Dr Timnit Gebru, who previously led a 12-person research team, was supposedly shown the door at Google this month for questioning an order not to publish findings which scrutinised the ethical integrity of AI and its potential to impact disadvantaged communities.

According to Google’s small-print, the more rigorous vetting process of research papers was originally designed to stop the disclosing of trade secrets, but recent developments point to a much broader practice than that, and one that may soon lead to big censorship disputes.

The explosion of research into the development and rapid integration of AI tech has led to upwards of 200 published papers in the last year alone, and as big proprietors of the technology – using AI to personalise YouTube users’ content feeds, for instance – Google is clearly looking to protect its reputation. In-fact, former employees at Google have even revealed that company officials called for research authors to ‘strike a positive tone’ when talking in-house developments or tech integration. Judging by the sheer outpouring of disgruntled ex-employees, it seems such interference is common too.

Despite assertions from Google that researchers have ‘substantial’ freedom with their work, senior scientists like Margaret Mitchell are becoming increasingly concerned for the company’s future under this new umbrella of inspection.

‘If we are researching the appropriate thing given our expertise, and we are not permitted to publish that on grounds that are not in line with high-quality peer review, then we’re getting into a serious problem of censorship,’ Margaret said in an interview with Reuters. Google has yet to respond to this growing air of trepidation.

Beyond the integration of AI, other topics deemed to fall under the ‘sensitive topics’ remit and therefore Google’s increased inspection include the oil industry, China, Iran, Israel, Covid-19, insurance, and location data.

You’d have to say plenty on the list are considered sensitive topics for good reason, but others – chiefly artificial intelligence – are raising eyebrows among those who’ve trusted Google implicitly for upwards of a decade. You’d expect the likes of Facebook, Apple, and Microsoft to avoid promoting criticism of lucrative technologies like AI where possible and shout their usefulness from the rooftops.

However, when it comes to a platform we all expect to be entirely factual and without bias, it’s a worry that Google maybe considering the ramifications of posting and deliberating whether or not certain studies are within its best interest to release.

For now, you can guarantee Google is taking its time with its response. We’ll have to wait and see.

Tech Editor London, UK

I’m Jamie (He/Him), the Editor in Chief at Thred. Keeping up with gaming and revolutionary technology is my forte, but when away from my keyboard, you’ll probably find me wrapped around a large Tango ice blast at the latest mediocre horror flick. Follow me on Twitter, LinkedIn and drop me some ideas/feedback via email.

Popular

Keep up with thred by signing up to our planet-positive newsletter!

More from thred.

Does the human brain have a microbiome?
Credit: Pexels
Science

Does the human brain have a microbiome?

Though it’s long been assumed that bacteria can’t survive in the human brain, neuroscientists have recently been surprised to discover that it may harbour all sorts of micro-organisms. In recent years, gut health has been all the rage. This is because our understanding of the function and importance of the microbiome that lives in our intestines has improved, particularly in relation to maintaining the immune system. A microbiome is a community...

By London, UK
Apple sued by Democratic Republic of Congo for illegal mining
Credit: Al Jazeera
News

Apple sued by Democratic Republic of Congo for illegal mining

The DRC’s lawyers have stated that tech giant Apple has knowingly sourced minerals from conflict zones in East Africa while publicly painting itself as sustainable and ethical.   The Democratic Republic of Congo has filed lawsuits in both Paris and Brussels claiming that tech-giant Apple purchased illegal ‘blood minerals’ from its conflict zones for use in its product lines. Filed against the Apple European subsidiaries, the lawsuit states that the company...

By London, UK
Tech companies exploring nuclear energy to power AI
Credit: Thred
Technology

Tech companies exploring nuclear energy to power AI

Leading tech companies are exploring the potential of nuclear energy as a sustainable and reliable power source to meet the growing energy demands of artificial intelligence. In recent years, since OpenAI dropped ChatGPT, the world has seen a surge in all things AI. From catalyzing a plethora of research to predictive analysis in data security, the presence of AI in our daily lives has become a norm. Powering this increase in...

By Kuala Lumpur, Indonesia
Trans youth are turning to TikTok for support
Credit: Thred
Social

Trans youth are turning to TikTok for support

In uncertain political times, America’s young LGBTQIA+ community are using social media as a vital crowdfunding tool.  The day after the 2024 US presidential election, thousands of trans youth across the country woke to a sense of a dread. Iris, a 20-year-old Black trans woman living in Texas, was one of them. ‘This changes everything’ she told Wired. ‘If I stay in the state now that going to...

By Brighton, UK
Accessibility