Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Do we ever have the right to comment on someone’s body?

Public fixation over Ariana Grande’s appearance has driven the star to retreat from the spotlight. Where do we draw the line between scrutiny and concern when it comes to women’s bodies? 

Ariana Grande has lived half of her life in the spotlight. She’s had a hugely successful music career during that time – achieving 10 US number one hits, 20 Grammy Award nominations, and three wins. She’s also moved into acting where she earned an Oscar nomination for her role as Galinda in Wicked. 

But Grande has also navigated a series of personal struggles on a public scale. In 2017, 22 people were killed in a suicide bomb attack at her concert in Machester. Grande later revealed she was dealing with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). A year later, her ex-boyfriend, rapper Mac Miller, died from an accidental overdose.

Grande has spoken about living with an ‘all-consuming’ grief as a result of these experiences – both exacerbated by a constant barrage of criticism and public scrutiny. But her celebrity status appeared to have finally taken its toll, when the star announced she would be taking a step back from the spotlight at the end of her ongoing Eternal Sunshine Tour which wraps in September.

The decision comes after months of discussion about Grande’s appearance, namely her body. First critics, then observers, and now fans have expressed concern about the star’s weight – and when the music video for her new song Petal dropped last week the comments reached a fever pitch.

One fan wrote on X that Grande ‘has become so thin that people are genuinely concerned.’ Others have called out those who’ve spoken on the singer’s weight, stating that ‘no-one has the right to comment on anyone else’s body or appearance.’ Any comment, however, has sharpened the focus on Grande from all angles.

Three years ago, Grande pleaded with fans not to talk about her body. Responding to a TikTok video, the star said there were ‘many different ways to look healthy and beautiful.’ But today, conversations around her physical appearance have only grown louder.

It’s a complicated topic, not least because it holds a mirror up to our societal discomfort with body image. Openly talking about a person’s weight is taboo – and rightly so – but it also greys the lines around our understanding of wellbeing and acceptance, particularly in the era of Ozempic.

When everyone is suddenly trying to be smaller, mental and physical health falls to the wayside. Compounding that with the complicated ethics of commenting on public figures and speculating about their personal situation, and navigating the Ariana Grande discourse becomes even more precarious.

We’ve normalised policing women under the guise of something more acceptable. And so the conversation surrounding Grande feels symptomatic of a much wider cultural shift.

Over the past week, social media has been consumed by another debate after creator Levi Coralynn argued that hating influencers has become a socially acceptable way of hating women. Her point wasn’t that influencers are beyond criticism, but that the label itself has become shorthand for dismissing women – a way of belittling female ambition and appearance under the guise of having a more legitimate grievance.

Concern may well be genuine for many people, but the language of concern can also become a socially acceptable vehicle for scrutiny. It allows us to dissect a woman’s body while feeling morally justified in doing so.

That’s exactly why these kinds of conversations gather so much momentum. They’re never just about the woman at their centre. They’re about the rest of us, and the impossible standards we’re expected to meet. They’re about the pressure to occupy as little space as possible while remaining effortlessly beautiful, and the collective anxiety that resurfaces whenever those standards begin to shift.

While we tell ourselves we’ve moved beyond reducing women to the way they look, moments like this suggest we haven’t.

The truth is we don’t know what’s happening in Ariana Grande’s life. The only thing we do know is that she has repeatedly asked people to stop discussing her appearance, and that the conversation has continued regardless.

But that doesn’t change the fact she is a public figure with a huge influence. Anyone who has struggled with body image knows that these images don’t exist in isolation. We are living through a cultural moment where extreme thinness has crept back into fashion. Bodies that only a few years ago would have been held up as symbols of harmful beauty standards are once again being celebrated, whether implicitly or explicitly.

For someone with a fanbase as young as Grande, this poses a huge risk. Fans have already shared worrying personal accounts of the impact Grande’s appearance has had on them – from inspiring restrictive behaviours to warping perceptions of health and food.

The discourse around Grande is evidence that two things can be true at once. It’s possible to feel genuine concern when looking at someone while also recognising that voicing that concern publicly may do more harm than good. The internet has convinced us that every observation deserves to become a discussion, and every discussion deserves an audience. And ultimately, Grande has now been hounded out of public life.

Women’s bodies have always been treated as open for debate, and no more so than those of women in the spotlight. But before we pile on with our two cents, we need to let the people who inhabit these bodies reclaim ownership of them. If that means a retreat to privacy, I hope Grande emerges stronger and happier.

Enjoyed this? Click here for more Gen Z focused culture stories.

Accessibility