Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Explaining the controversy around the Mexican song ‘Tu boda’

Is it problematic for musicians to use femicide as inspiration for their art? 

In the last few weeks, the public has expressed mixed opinions over the release of the song “Tu boda” by Oscar Maydon & Fuerza Regida. 

The song has gone viral on social media and has secured the number one spot on Spotify Mexico, despite – or perhaps in spite of – the serious controversy surrounding it.

Assessing online narratives, it’s clear that two main perspectives on the record have been expressed by fans.

On one hand, there are people who believe Tu boda is a piece of art that speaks to the reality of violence against women taking place across the country.

They suggest that while this type of violence is not okay, the song itself is a work of fiction.

Others say that people are simply criticising the song for being part of the “Corridos tumbados” genre, a genre that is heavily disliked by older people and successful artists.

They argue that if the song was sung in English or played as another genre, there would not be this commotion.

Let’s take a look at the song lyrics, which presents a first-person narration of a man scorned after a breakup.

The song continues, revealing how the artist plans to murder his ex-partner on their wedding day.

He then details his plan to commit suicide and be together “in the afterlife”, but in the end he goes against what he planned, ultimately committing suicide.

At the last second, he expresses regret for making plans to harm his ex-partner, and commits suicide.

People who have taken offense at the song and its themes have asked that it be removed from streaming platforms. 

They make this request because they live within the social context of Mexico, where 9 to 10 women are murdered daily in the country.

They point out that it’s possible that when a popular music artist sings about such intense themes of violence, femicide, and suicide, it could incite or even glorify such actions – even if this is not their intention. 

It is also important to note that there are states in the country that prohibit public performances that could encourage crime or violence. Artists who violate these laws are often hit with hefty fines. 

I’ll leave it up for you to decide, is Tu boda an accurate, necessary representation of real life or should it be removed from music platforms?

Accessibility