Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Social media loves telling you what’s wrong with your face

Why are so many cosmetic doctors dishing out unsolicited advice on our appearance? 

Cosmetic surgery is not the taboo it once was. These days, aesthetic enhancements are accepted as part and parcel of the modern beauty regimen – and celebrities who forgo them are considered trailblazers.

The normalisation of cosmetic medicine has triggered complex debates. Some believe it’s a blessing that once ‘secretive’ procedures are now out in the open – demystifying unrealistic beauty ideals and making us all feel better about ourselves.

Others believe it’s a slippery slope, and that our growing obsession with the many ways to change our faces is exacerbating toxic beauty standards. Whatever side of the fence you sit on, the appetite for aesthetic treatments is growing.

The global aesthetic medicine market is projected to increase at an annual rate of 9.8% from 2024 to 2034, as advancements in technology make the pursuit of ‘natural’ artifice more attainable.

Dr Wassim Taktouk, a cosmetic doctor, anticipates a trend shift toward ‘Quiet Luxury Face’, where individuals opt for a compound of several subtle enhancements over drastic one-off procedures.

The age of those seeking aesthetic treatments has also dropped, with 62% of Brits aged 18-24 considering non-surgical interventions to ‘prevent’ rather than ‘cure’ ageing.

Whichever way you look at it, the cosmetic medical industry is set to enjoy a very prosperous future. And it’s being bolstered by social media.

It’s no secret that digital platforms have made our favourite celebrities more accessible than ever. And while we’re establishing parasocial relationships, spaces like Instagram and TikTok have also become breeding grounds for interrogating the lives of famous people at levels once considered impossible.

In the 90s and early 2000s, tabloid magazines provided a tool for criticizing famous faces and bodies, but social media has replaced this as an interactive environment for sharing unsolicited insights – especially as they pertain to celebrity aesthetic treatments.

Because more and more stars are choosing transparency over secrecy when it comes to plastic surgery, many of us feel entitled to drop in our two cents. Even, it turns out, medical professionals.

As if we needed any more voices telling us what’s wrong with our faces, now cosmetic practitioners are finding success by sharing in-depth analysis of celebrities’ looks. London-based Dr Zayn Khalid Majeed is one doctor-slash-influencer who’s found a dedicated following by unpacking famous faces on TikTok.

But his ‘advice’ recently landed him in hot water after a video criticizing Troye Sivan’s facial structure drew backlash from the singer. In a now-deleted video, Majeed said Sivan appeared to be showing signs of ‘twink death’.

The ‘twink’ look refers to younger, slim gay men with a boyish look – an aesthetic for which Sivan has become somewhat of a blueprint. Majeed told his followers that the pop star could do with a list of various cosmetic ‘improvements’ to fix his ‘problem areas’ and ‘volume loss’, including skin boosters and dermal filler.

Comments beneath the video were quick to call out Majeed’s ‘unsolicited’ advice, and the video eventually drew a lengthy essay from Sivan on Substack.

‘I’ve struggled with my body image for a lot of my life, as I’m sure most people have,’ he wrote. ‘What good is money and modern medicine if not to fix all of these flaws that this random… plastic surgeon told me I have?’

Majeed said he ‘felt terrible’ and commended Sivan’s ‘raw and vulnerable’ response. But he also told the BBC he intends to continue making videos analysing celebrity faces because it’s what his followers want to see.

The normalization of this behaviour is the real problem. Diving into the various problems with a person’s face and listing out the string of ways they could ‘fix’ them was once the domain of the sleazy tabloid – but now medical doctors are at the forefront. Nobody is batting an eyelid.

It’s something content creator Samantha Rizzo finds ‘mind-boggling.’

‘I appreciate it if you’re using your clients and they consent to their before, during, and after photos,’ Rizzo said. ‘I feel a little icky when they’re just taking the celebrity’s picture.’

‘Just because they’re famous doesn’t mean you have the right to pick them apart.’ These videos also have a profound effect on the people viewing them. When we spend so much time interrogating the features of other faces, our perception of our own becomes warped – and our desire for cosmetic enhancement increases.

There is also something uniquely destabilising about hearing these assessments from medical professionals. Doctors are not just influencers; they are authority figures. Their words carry the implied weight of expertise and objectivity. So when a cosmetic practitioner points out a ‘problem area,’ it lands like a diagnosis more than anything else.

This is not to say cosmetic medicine is inherently unethical, or that people seeking aesthetic treatments are misguided. Autonomy over one’s own body matters. And indeed for many, procedures can be genuinely life-affirming. But autonomy becomes compromised when insecurity is actively and publicly manufactured.

Social media loves telling you what’s wrong with your face. It thrives on the promise that self-improvement is always one procedure away. But I think we forgot, somewhere along the line, that faces aren’t problems to be solved.

Enjoyed this article? Click here for more Gen Z focused change stories.

Accessibility