A video of French brand Sézane exploiting an elderly Indigenous woman for their summer campaign has emerged as the fashion community fervidly mourn the late André Leon Talley. These distinct responses to Otherness prove that the industry’s approach to difference is still a strenuous affair.
A video of an elderly Mexican woman dancing to music on an impromptu set for French fashion brand Sézane sparked widespread outrage on social media last week, and a ‘sharp rebuke’ from the Mexican government.
Sézane staged the photoshoot with an elderly Indigenous woman from the Zapotec community of Teotitlan del Valle, in the state of Oaxaca on the 7th January.
A video taken by a local – an Oaxacan resident who had been hired to help Sézane on the shoot – shows the crew encouraging the woman to dance and sing to Mary Hopkins’ 1968 hit ‘Those Were the Days’.
The video was posted to Instagram with an outraged caption: ‘Sézane didn’t care, and almost like the woman was a prop, they dressed up the woman […] and made her dance by offering her $200 MXN or around $10 USD.’
The controversial photos were taken three days into a planned nine-day shoot – an impromptu set up that strayed from the brand’s ‘mood board’ featuring models lounging in upscale hotels.
The video was quickly shared across the internet, reaching Manuela Cortes, a textile artist and art curator. Cortes posted the video with the comment, ‘Indigenous cultures treated like a display cabinet to pick and choose from. No respect. No morals.’
Cortes later spoke to Vice News, calling out the brand – and fashion more broadly – for exploiting Indigenous peoples and locals to push a brand agenda that has nothing to do with the culture they make efforts to portray.
The footage eventually reached the Mexican government – its Secretary of Culture accused the French fashion company of ‘manipulating, using, and making a spectacle’ of elderly people from Indigenous villages as ‘part of their publicity’.
Sézane’s actions speak to longstanding debates over cultural appropriation in fashion. More significantly, fashions reliance on the exoticisation of an ‘Other’; the consumption of difference, and the portrayal of non-Western, non-White cultures as extreme versions of themselves.
Débora Krischke Leitão has written extensively about the construction of the exotic ‘Other’ in the industry. Her paper, ‘We, the Others’ unpicks French fashion’s depiction of Brazilian culture as a way of consuming that which is different.
The exoticisation of distant cultures in arts and fashion is nothing new. From Josephine Baker’s banana skirt to the appropriation of West African masks by Pablo Picasso, Western creatives have relied on stealing that which they are not in order to create an image of difference, a fantasy of Otherness, that bolsters their own acclaim.
British Vogue’s February issue celebrates ‘fashion now’, spotlighting nine African models under the creative direction of Edward Enninful.
‘Fashion has indeed changed’, wrote Enninful on his Instagram last week. And in many ways, this rings true. Enninful himself is a testament to the glass ceilings being shattered in the industry’s most prominent spaces. But while outlets like Vogue, and multi-billion-dollar design houses like Chanel, Dior, and Prada may dominate the landscape of fashion, they are just a tiny fraction of its global machine.
In the age of social media influencers and fast fashion brands, fashion still belongs to the skinny and the white. Brands like Sézane are all too common, churning out diverse content, booking ‘different’ models, to push a public image of inclusivity. But this is so often a façade to sell product, with internal structures still boasting CEOs from privileged backgrounds, and overwhelmingly white cis-het teams.
At the time of writing this article on fashion’s hunger for difference, the sudden death of André Leon Talley struck a poignant chord. The term ‘icon’ perhaps suited nobody better than Talley, who worked his way into the industry’s tightest circles with an encyclopaedic knowledge of fashion and a sharp sense of humour so often absent from these elitist spaces.
But Talley was also the poster boy for ‘different’. He was a plus size, Black, queer man born into a Jim Crow era South. His death is a marker of how far fashion has come in structurally embracing Otherness, rather than simply utilising it for profit. But the outpourings of grief for Talley are also a marker of how far fashion has left to go.
Commentators have described him as a ‘heroic outsider’, ‘the only one’. Talley was one in a million for his warm spirit and outrageous creative flair, but his Blackness, his rise from a working-class community to the upper echelons of fashion society, is what truly stands out in a predominantly white, Western, wealthy world. He is – sadly – one of the only ones.
Fashion’s relationship with difference is still a toxic one. But for an industry built on the backs of others – exploited garment workers, caricatured Indigenous peoples, the innovative visions of those from societies most marginalised communities, and the ripped-off ideas of independent designers – perhaps it always will be.
I’m Flo, (She/Her) a Senior Remote Writer at Thred. I recently completed a Masters in Visual Anthropology, and seek to interrogate the ways digital spaces can amplify marginalised voices in the arts and cultural sectors. Follow me on LinkedIn or ping me some feedback via email.
Statistics from the International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery reveal that eyelid surgery (officially known as blepharoplasty) is now the most sought after procedure in the US. Why do people want to cut skin from their eyelids?
For decades, breast augmentations and liposuction were the two most popular aesthetic procedures sought by patients in the United States. In recent years though, more and more people are headed to aesthetic surgeons...
The Dutch designer’s latest collection Sympoiesis featured a glowing ‘live dress’ grown with 125 million bioluminescent algae, blurring the lines between nature, fashion, and technology.
The world of couture has a long-standing reputation for pushing the boundaries of what can be done with fashion.
From incorporating unique sewing techniques, creating breathtaking structures, and incorporating novel materials, each new fashion week sees designers deliver on innovative creations that impress and allure.
Dutch designer...
As we grow, we often let go of things – whether it’s a material object, a friendship, or something more. But do we know how to survive the loss?
For the first time in a while, I had no doubts that this was going to be an amazing year for me. I was finally consistent with exercising, meeting my friends more often and making new ones, and going on an...
Recent studies have found associations between inflammation, environmental circumstances, and lifestyle factors. While this research has reconceptualised the link between inflammation and ageing, it has also revealed how a lack of choice for young working-class people will result in negative health consequences not just now, but in the long term.
With the recent heatwave the UK has been facing, you might have spent a weekend stripped off and sweating, moving...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.