Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Why Justin Bieber shouldn’t be chart begging

Justin’s taken a leaf out of DJ Khaled’s book and has asked his fans to stream his new single ‘Yummy’ on loop – even when they’re asleep.

By now I’m guessing you’ve probably listened to Justin Bieber’s first solo single in nearly five years, the obviously-written-for-Tik-Tok track ‘Yummy’ that was released at the beginning of the month.

With a bog standard R&B instrumental and a monotonous hook that repeats the song’s title over and over, Justin’s return has been met with a widespread shrug from music critics and fans alike. It’s fine, but nothing to write home about.

That universal ‘meh’ response has reflected in the track’s performance on the Billboard charts, as it failed to reach the number one spot in its first week. It’s a surprising and unexpected turnout considering Justin is arguably one of the biggest pop stars ever – and it seems his management aren’t happy either.

Justin asked fans to mindlessly stream and purchase ‘Yummy’ from both Spotify and iTunes via a now deleted Instagram repost several days ago, advising that it’s best to listen at low volume or ‘when you’re asleep’. Other tips also include using a VPN to pretend you’re in the US when you’re not, creating playlists with only ‘Yummy’ on them, and linking directly to the YouTube music video wherever possible. Basically, fans should just spam the song to absolute death in order to help the song reach the top position.

This kind of behaviour is the worst example of big name artists abusing the streaming system to gain accolades they don’t deserve. It’s inauthentic, lame, and unnecessary. He’s also not the first to do it. Labels frequently adopt new ways to try and help numbers and chart positions including deluxe albums, giveaways, and shorter EPs that encourage multiple repeat listens.

It’s further evidence that pop music in 2020 has reached a bizarre place where the song itself is created with social media apps (particularly TikTok) in mind. Algorithms, length, album covers, and the overall marketing of the product are all essential elements in creating a popular track, often taking precedence over the quality of the song itself. Such seems to be the case with ‘Yummy’.

Why is it wrong for Justin to cheat his way to number one?

First off, demanding that young listeners take time out of their day to repeatedly stream your song when they probably don’t want to is a bit dodgy, let alone suggesting they fork out extra cash to buy multiple copies off of iTunes.

Artificially boosting your own numbers is unfair on your competition, particularly if the singles you’re up against are far more inspired and genuine than your own. ‘Yummy’ has been battling Roddy Ricch’s ‘The Box’ for the top spot this week, which is an original trap banger that includes some introspective verses in there for good measure. It’s far more interesting of a listen than Bieber’s effort, which sounds like something an algorithm could have clunked together in about an hour.

What’s worse is that Bieber doesn’t even need it. Cheating the system and getting yourself a number one is one thing, but it becomes even more unfair when you consider the magnitude of Bieber’s brand and name. He’s not a struggling artist and has remained one of the most commercially friendly acts out there for over a decade.

‘Yummy’ doesn’t need to be number one in any capacity – it’s purely for bragging rights.

Who else has tried to push themselves to the top?

Bieber isn’t the first to try and boost himself to number one using questionable tactics, and he’s also not the only artist who’s struggled to accept that their music just isn’t performing as well as they imagined it would. Take DJ Khaled, for example, who threw not-so-subtle shade at Tyler The Creator when IGOR beat his album to the number one spot in 2019.

https://youtu.be/qg_oMrJPiz4

Nicki Minaj also took to Twitter when her last album Queen didn’t come out at the top spot, having been beaten by Travis Scott’s ASTROWORLD. She blamed Spotify and Drake for the album’s performance and declared that both were attempting to ‘teach her a lesson’.

Both of these artists reactions to their work not being number one speaks volumes for the weight the charts have on their ideas of success. Justin’s team will be just as frantic and distressed that they haven’t bagged the number one with a big return single, I’m sure, and right now there’s most likely a board of directors wondering how exactly they’re going to market Bieber’s next single.

Hopefully they don’t resort to encouraging fan manipulation of streaming numbers, as it’s a low and petty way to move yourself up the charts when you haven’t really earned it. Many Bieber fans will be younger, too, and far more likely to buy into these kind of practices than Roddy Ricch’s fan base. Pop music in 2020 is all about social media – but it should still be a fair game that isn’t manipulated by dishonest streams and multiple purchases.

Accessibility