Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Kai Cenat and the influencer charity controversy

Kai Cenat is under scrutiny again, but this time it’s not about setting off fireworks in his room or being shite at Elden Ring. It involves a school in Nigeria, and we’re trying to find the line between philanthropy and clout chasing.

Earlier this year, Kai travelled to Nigeria with fellow creators Fanum and Duke Dennis. During the visit, he revealed he’d funded the construction of a new school, with footage showing excited students, new classrooms, and a plaque bearing his name.

It was framed as a feel-good moment – a big name using his platform to give back. Unlike the Sadio Mane’s of this world, however, the narrative around Kai has started to swiftly unravel. As always, the internet wants some answers.

While Kai framed the project as a success, online commentators and fans have voiced skepticism. YouTube critics have claimed there’s been little visible progress despite large sums being raised, while others question whether the funding and planning are as solid as first presented.

Critics are now rightly questioning whether the school was ever a sustainable project, or just a PR stunt to look good on camera and garner favour on socials. This has reignited an ongoing conversation about influencer charity, and whether acts of supposed philanthropy from people in the space should come under greater scrutiny.

Currently, the online debate is split. Kai’s defenders argue he donated in good faith, that he wasn’t responsible for maintaining the school after the cameras stopped rolling, while others feel he used the visit primarily for content without following up to ensure the kids benefited in any tangible way.

The situation has shades of previous controversies frankly too numerous to mention. MrBeast has an entire rap sheet for hyper viral donations, and other household names have pricked suspicions for altruistic acts overseas. It’s becoming an increasingly relevant conversation, and the argument that any act of charity is commendable is continually proven to have more holes than a hedgehog’s pillow.

Unlike some previous cases, there’s little doubt that Kai’s intentions were pure. He’s proven to be affable and charming when dealing with fans in public – including our own Luke Smith at Cannes – and though sometimes controversial, his mishaps usually appear to be born out of naivety and overexcitement, rather than malice or insidious scheming.

Nevertheless, the excuse of youth and gullibility can’t protect one from accountability, especially when they happen to exert as much influence as Kai does. Impulse doesn’t work with charity, especially if you’re building something from the ground up – like a school.

There’s staff to pay, entire systems to implement, and constant maintenance that must be directed behind the scenes, otherwise, any lasting impact simply cannot be achieved. The nature of this undertaking doesn’t seamlessly gel with the spontaneous and jam-packed life of a 22-year-old streamer – the biggest on Twitch, by the way – so we’ll see if he can deliver.

Without wishing to condemn the lad, it’s not excessive to call the undertaking overzealous. For someone who is undoubtedly a young marketing genius (and that’s not an overreach), you’d expect Kai to be wary of fueling the naysayers, especially in a time where people are fed up of charitable acts being packaged like reaction videos.

This isn’t in the same ballpark as Hstikkytokky throwing cash at waiters 24 hours after fighting partygoers in Ibiza, but it still gives off the distinct whiff of spectacle over substance. To uplift the community and claw back credibility, real care has to be taken, and merely writing a cheque doesn’t always cut it.

Following the backlash, keeping a low profile – yeh, right – would have been advisable. The course of action you maybe wouldn’t recommend would be to announce a partnership with Fortnite, and a grinning new avatar sharing your likeness. Suffice to say, the flames are still being fanned.

It highlights a growing disconnect between the image social media influencers project online and the impact they have offline. You can’t dabble in schools, hospitals, or entire communities without foresight and the willingness to stay the course. You’re either all in, or don’t bother.

It’s almost as though giving money to existing charities with their own infrastructure and networks doesn’t cut the mustard in terms of an eye-grabbing thumbnail or video title. Ultimately, the optics aren’t great right now, and people aren’t going to just shrug when the fallout has potentially huge real-life consequences. They’re certainly not going to give the benefit of the doubt, either.

Building hype is easy, building trust takes work. We just hope Kai pulls it out of the bag – literally.

Accessibility