Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Is Florida planning to end vaccine mandates?

The US state would be the first to stop vaccines being a requirement for children attending school. 

The Trump administration – and specifically Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. – has made its negative stance on vaccines pretty clear from the offset. But in the second term of aTrump presidency, national distrust of these vital medications has only grown.

Now, Florida is aiming to become the first US state to cancel all vaccine mandates, meaning children won’t be required to receive jabs before attending school.

Florida’s surgeon general, Dr. Joseph A. Ladapo, was joined by Governor Ron DeSantis to announce that their administration will officially be ‘working to end’ all vaccine mandates statewide.

It all sounds a bit Black Mirror – not least because public health experts have long credited mandatory vaccinations as key to limiting the spread of infectious diseases in modern society. But alas, it seems Republicans really do want you to have ownership of your own body (unless you’re a pregnant woman, of course).

‘Who am I to tell you what your child should put in your body?’ said Lapado, likening the mandates to ‘slavery’ during a public announcement this week.

‘I don’t have that right. Your body is a gift from god.’

To no surprise, Lapado has been heavily criticised by doctors and health groups for spreading misinformation. And besides the very real dangers posed by removing vaccine mandates, this kind of legislation screams of Western privilege.

Many of the world’s most vulnerable countries are desperately trying to access life-saving vaccines to curb the spread of diseases like polio and measles. In 2024, over 14.3 million children under the age of 1 didn’t receive basic immunisation vaccines (that’s 171,000 less than the year prior).

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimate that more than 50 million deaths can be prevented worldwide through immunisation efforts in the years between 2021 and 2030.

It’s ironic that while some may believe withholding vaccines is in their child’s best interest, they’re actually putting both their child and the children of countless other parents in harm’s way. It may be your child’s body and your choice, but what about the other children who will be made vulnerable to the exposure of dangerous diseases?

As Rachel Varina so aptly put it, while ‘politicians are talking about ‘parental freedom’ […] parents like me are stuck in the middle trying to figure out what this means for our actual kids – you know, the ones still licking playground equipment and coughing directly into each others mouths.’

Democratic state lawmaker Anna Eskamani decried the plan as ‘reckless and dangerous’, labelling it a ‘public health disaster in the making for the Sunshine State.’

In Florida, children are currently required to receive vaccines against multiple illnesses including chicken pox, hepatitis B, measles, mumps and polio. The World Health Organisation states that immunisation like this has saved at least 154 million lives – mostly infants – in the past 50 years.

Of course, DeSantis and Lapado aren’t exactly newcomers to America’s anti-vax playbook. Florida has already carved itself out as a kind of testing ground for ‘medical freedom’, from rejecting Covid-19 mandates to encouraging ‘parental rights’ rhetoric around health and education.

To their supporters, this is about resisting government overreach. But to their critics, it’s gambling with children’s lives for the sake of political theatre.

In 2019, the US saw its highest number of measles cases in 25 years, with the majority linked to communities with low vaccine uptake. Globally, cases of polio – once on the brink of eradication – are rising again. These statistics are a reminder that diseases are blind to politics.

Parents in Florida are now facing an impossible balancing act. Do you keep your child in a school where vaccine coverage could plummet, raising the risk of exposure to preventable illnesses? Or do you join the slow drift of families considering homeschooling, private education, or even leaving the state entirely?

For many, neither option is financially or logistically viable.

‘The short story’ Varina writes, ‘is that, without mandates, the decision to vaccinate is left entirely up to parents. And while that might sound like freedom, it also means the safety net schools once provided disappears.’

And the consequences of cutting vaccines out isn’t just medical, either. It’s estimated that vaccines have saved around $540 million in direct healthcare costs and $2.7 million in indirect costs for children born between 1994 and 2023.

The truth is that vaccines are victims of their own success. When generations grow up without witnessing classmates die of measles or live in iron lungs because of polio, it’s easy to imagine that such dangers are relics of the past. But the only reason these horrors seem distant is because vaccines pushed them there.

Accessibility