Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

How systemic educational failures triggered the violent protests in France

Students, teachers, and parents have taken to the street to protest France’s crippling education infrastructure. However, as the movement started to gain nationwide traction, so did violence, driven by clashes with the riot police.

These past few weeks have seen intense waves of violence associated with student-led protests in France. What started as a local walkout by teachers at a high school in Créteil quickly turned into a nationwide movement.

Now teenagers across the country are barricading school gates with wheelie bins and taking to the streets, fed up with the cracks that are now being exposed in the nation’s education system.

The ongoing protests reflect a growing frustration with the system’s chronic staff shortages, deteriorating school infrastructure, and the inequalities that come with its Parcoursup system.

Difficulties in recruiting teachers have left an annual deficit of 4,000 teaching positions being unfilled. This is all while the proportion of students attending schools with staff shortages rose by 50% in four years.

This shortage is significant enough that 88% of short-notice class cancellations cannot be covered by other teachers. Additionally, 11% of secondary, and 3% of primary teachers are deemed inexperienced for teaching.

Meanwhile, with many school buildings constructed in the mid-to-late 20th century, they are ill-equipped to handle the rising climate demands. Some of these classrooms have reached 35°C to 40°C during periods of intense heatwaves without centralised air conditioning, while unforgiving winters are supported by a lack of modern thermal insulation.

Vermin sightings and burst pipes also happen to be frequent occurrences in many of these poorly maintained schools.

Compounding these issues is severe underfunding. While France spends heavily on education, with an estimated €64 billion allocated to it, these funds are unevenly distributed across the sector.

For instance, while it spends 24% more per student for upper secondary – higher than the OECD average – this spending is much lower in primary schools. Working-class suburbs receive fewer experienced, permanent teachers and less municipal infrastructure investment than affluent city centres.

Then there’s Parcoursup, which is the nation’s centralized online application portal used by final-year high school students to apply for undergraduate university programs and higher education courses. Although universities’ application evaluation criteria remain unknown, Parcoursup has been repeatedly accused of favouring applicants from elite urban schools over those from working-class suburbs.

With admission results released on a rolling basis over several months during the final baccalauréat exam preparation, many high-achieving students are chucked into long waiting lists without any idea if they are attending higher education.

The protests

These everyday grievances were what initially brought high school students and teachers to the streets, voicing their concerns, starting at a high school in Créteil, with teachers walking out over staffing shortages.

High schoolers led by 17-year-old Cheick Sanogo joined in by blockading the school gates in solidarity instead of just sitting in empty classrooms, with videos of the schools’ poor conditions and missing staff spreading rapidly on social media, nationwide.

Soon, many major cities in France started to make barricades from wheelie bins, construction pallets, and chain locks with over 350 high schools being heavily disrupted by the end of September. Riot police are in the streets and the active deployment of tear gas and pepper spray is being used at school gates to clear entrances, resulting in violent clashes and hundreds being detained.

Seeing that the crisis in secondary education directly bleeds into higher education, major universities joined the strike, officially bringing Parcoursup into the picture.

With the strikes now in their third week, several disturbing instances of violence have been reported including one student losing a hand to a stun grenade, and a reported 7,000 arrests have been made.

The government’s response

To ease the protesters, Education Minister Edouard Geffray announced that an emergency deployment of 3,000 substitute teachers to 200 deeply affected schools. However, student unions subsequently rejected the offer and demanded a €10 billion emergency education budget, to ease the protest.

The government also attempted to shift the focus of the protests by accusing far-left opposition parties of exploiting the protests by encouraging students to maintain blockades, all for political gain. There were unverified claims pushed by the government that masked rioters had infiltrated these protests as an excuse to clash with the police.

Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu went on to emphasise a no tolerance stance for violence and property damage, which is the primary justification for riot squads being out in force. An estimated 500 schools have forcibly been closed since the protests started.

This temporary deployment of substitute teachers offers little more than a band-aid on a crisis that has systemic roots. Until the government addresses the deeper issues that these students and teachers face every day, the frustration burning from within those blockades will remain and grow.

Enjoyed this? Click here for more Gen Z focused change stories.

Accessibility