Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

Can Hermosa deliver US minerals without environmental cost?

Though the project is a vital strategic asset for the US, its reliance on advanced tech for mitigation techniques have failed to ease local anxieties about water security and the environment.

In the past two years, the US government has placed significant emphasis in obtaining rare earth minerals. From EVs to precision weapons, these minerals have become an essential commodity in the global economy. However, global sanctions on their export have created harder competition for nations to develop the necessary industries, utilising these minerals.

Acting as the poster child for the US critical minerals strategy is the South32 Hermosa project. Located in southern Arizona, this multibillion-dollar mining project was the first to have been federally fast tracked after being deemed essential to national interests.

What makes this project special is the site’s two primary deposits, Taylor and Clark. The Taylor Deposit holds one of the world’s largest undeveloped Zinc resources in the world, alongside contents of Lead and Silver.

On the other hand, the Clark Deposit focused on Battery-Grade Manganese which is a big deal because the US currently has zero domestic production of this element. Another high-priority exploration target within the broader site also found the presence copper.

Yet, tapping into vast previously untouched domestic deposits isn’t all Hermosa brings. After decades of exporting raw ore only to buy back refined minerals from China, the US is finally reclaiming its industrial sovereignty via Hermosa, because the project also includes its own processing facilities.

However, just like any other mining project, Hermosa brings in as much caveats as it does benefits.


The Patagonia Mountains

These mountains where Hermosa is being developed is known to be a Sky Island ecosystem with species not ordinarily found elsewhere. In fact, the US Forest Service identified 12 endangered species such as the Jaguar and Mexican Spotted Owl that could have their habitats severely upended by the mine.

Conservationists warn the mine lies within a vital US–Mexico migration corridor, where heavy industrial activity could permanently disrupt the movement of large mammals.

Compounding concerns are water issues, as the project relies on dewatering, a process that involves pumping out large volumes of water to prevent the mine tunnels from flooding.

For the entire run of the project, it’s estimated that 195,000 acre-feet of water would be pumped out, lowering the area’s water volume, and resulting in nearby residential wells running dry. With the dense populations of flora and fauna in the area, their water dependent lives are also left hanging.


South32’s solution

Well, despite these issues, South32 claims these issues pose no concern due to the project being ‘powered by advanced technology and innovation’.

For starters, the project’s design is said to be using 90% less water than other regional mines via efficient underground mining. The company also intends to use dry-stack tailings where mine waste is filtered to remove most water and stacked like dry dirt piles.

The company emphasised its plans on monitoring the area’s seeps, springs, and wells while providing community support to protect private wells.

Hermosa committed to a no net loss standard of biodiversity too. This includes keeping the mine entirely underground, creating wildlife corridors to maintain migration routes, and active monitoring of the overall ecosystem.


Will history repeat itself?

While the company promotes its advanced tech as key to environmental protection, many locals remain sceptical and for good reason.

Specifically, lab tests from last October which revealed Antimony levels of 6.23 micrograms per liter in the water discharged into local creeks by Hermosa – where the legal state limit is 6.0.

Though the company decided to upgrade its water treatment plant with continued monitoring, claiming compliance through adaptive measures, they have done little to ease local anxieties.

The reality is that such distrust is deeply rooted in Arizona’s grim mining legacy, where locals see Hermosa as history just waiting to be repeated. Not too long ago, abandoned uranium mines on Navajo lands leached heavy metals into soil and water, causing kidney disease, cancers, and livestock deaths with cleaning efforts still incomplete to this day.

In Patagonia, it’s only natural for residents to fear similar contamination – with the prosperity of endangered species on the line too.

For local communities, South32’s assurances may ring hollow, overshadowed by fears of repeated broken promises and long-term environmental harm.

Enjoyed this? Click here for more Gen Z focused change stories.

Accessibility