The UK’s deadliest mass shooting since 2010 has sparked a debate about whether participation in violent incel culture should be regarded as a form of terrorism.
Two weeks ago, a gunman named Jake Davison open fired in Plymouth, killing five people – including his own mother and a 3-year-old girl – before turning the weapon on himself.
Looking for a motive, police searched the shooter’s home, finding evidence on his computer of regular engagement with the incel movement across various online social platforms.
Comprised of mainly men, the incel movement’s core values have ‘themes of self-loathing and grievance’ which at times transform into violence.
The group’s name derives from the shortened phrase ‘involuntary celibate’ and members relate to one another through the shared predicament of being unable to find a willing sexual partner – despite their intense longing for a romantic relationship.
Across online forums, narratives of self-pity morph into misogyny, where women are demonised and blamed for the incel’s feelings of sexual rejection.
From this, violent behaviour against women somehow becomes not only normalised, but justifiable in the eyes of the community. At the same time, traditionally masculine men are maliciously targeted for being seen as superior.
Thus, virtually anyone with a perceived sex life can unknowingly become a scapegoat for an incels’ own personal feelings of sexual rejection and inferiority – two concepts Davison had allegedly connected with while participating in forums.
Gathering inspiration from The Matrix’s red and blue pill, which offer world truths or ignorance respectively, the incel’s ‘black pill’ contains the defeatist notion that those born unattractive have no chance of improving – their fate of being alone forever sealed.
An incel ‘taking the black pill’ means to swallow this ‘truth’, viewing any kind of affection or romantic attention from others as suspicious and disingenuous.
Police discovered that before the shooting in Plymouth, Davison had subscribed to YouTube channels which advocated for the black pill ideology – one of which has over 17,000 subscribers.
In a video posted to his own channel, Davison denied identifying as an incel but said that he could relate to those like him, who have ‘had nothing but themselves.’
He also discussed the black pill theory regularly online.
As a result, many are confused about why police wouldn’t treat the mass shooting as an act of terror, even after gaining awareness of the shooter’s affiliation with incel activity.
How prevalent is incel violence?
Incel ideologies have motivated numerous mass murders and other acts of violence, most notably in the US and Canada. Researchers now predict that the UK’s incel community is growing.
News stories and academic papers on the subject are riddled with claims that the extreme end of the culture is indeed very dangerous and radicalised.
Yet the debate on whether to label incels as terrorists has found a legislative solution difficult to pin down.
On one hand, most incels are thought to be harmless, socially inept members of an online-only boy’s club fuelled by performative empty threats and deep self-wallowing.
Jacob Ware, a terrorism researcher who studies the incel movement told The Guardian, ‘incels display very high levels of mental health issues. They display high levels of a history of bullying. This is a movement that is desperately sad.’
However, Ware does not dismiss their behaviour, saying ‘incel violence is ideological violence against civilians, to prove an ideological point or create psychological fear. That makes it terrorism.’
Repeated news reports, police and politicians all saying this is not terror related. This is shocking and shameful. Extremist misogyny, male supremacy, sees women die all over the world, including repeatedly in incel massacres. We cannot tackle it if we do not name it
A section of the Terrorism Act of 2000 defines terrorism as ‘the use or threat of the violence for the purpose of advancing a political, religious, racial or ideological cause’.
But in response to the shooting, The Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation in the UK, Jonathan Hall has hesitated to categorise the incident in Plymouth as so – or to properly categorise it at all.
He explained: ‘It fits rather uneasily into the way the authorities understand ideologies. It seems part of right-wing terrorism, but it is not really. In fact, it is quite separate from it. It is a different sort of ideology.’
Finding a solution
It’s obvious that incel culture highlights the ‘online disinhibition effect’, whereby online spaces make it easier to express thoughts and ideas that one would otherwise never say or do in person – until a minority member of the group does.
On this note, many argue that incel activity is not a black and white issue because individuals participate with ideologies to different degrees and on various levels of the spectrum, making it difficult to monitor.
In the future, government officials will likely have to revisit the problem of classifying instances of violence committed by incel members. Are they hate crimes? Is it terrorism?
Deputy Editor & Content Partnership ManagerLondon, UK
I’m Jessica (She/Her). I’m the Deputy Editor & Content Partnership Manager at Thred. Originally from the island of Bermuda, I specialise in writing about ocean health and marine conservation, but you can also find me delving into pop culture, health and wellness, plus sustainability in the beauty and fashion industries. Follow me on Twitter, LinkedIn and drop me some ideas/feedback via email.
The anticipation of having a baby is often clouded with uncertainty for Africa’s women as well as their families and healthcare providers due to an overwhelming number of pregnancy complications.
According to WHO, annually there are over 2 million stillbirths in the world, over half occurring in Sub-Saharan Africa.
These stillborn deaths are often preventable. Poor access to prenatal care, shortages of qualified health care providers, delayed responses to emergencies,...
Would people be more inclined to recycle their waste if they had a slim chance of winning $1,000 each time? Unsurprisingly, the data says yes.
A sense of moral responsibility or pang of guilt not cutting it? How about four figures of cold hard cash for that garbage?
Around 10 US states are already reimbursing people with a few cents for their empty bottles or cans, but what if the odd...
Dubbed ‘High Earners, Not Rich Yet’ (or Henrys), young Brits are feeling the pinch thanks to tax traps and inflation.
Unless you’ve found yourself in a high-paying job (or grew up with a silver spoon between your lips), £100k probably sounds like a lot of money. But young people earning these six figures claim to be struggling financially – both in the UK and across the pond.
Henrys, particularly...
Now he’s afraid he might get impeached.
Donald Trump’s election against Kamala Harris shocked many, with the former narrowly securing 49.8% of the popular vote compared to the latter’s 48.3%. He secured a clean sweep of all seven swing states, which ultimately secured him a second term.
What makes his return to the Oval Office striking is that he delivered exactly what he preached during his campaign. Prominently among these...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
0 comments
