Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

The hidden struggle of gay men in urban areas across India

In the shadows of India’s cities, a pervasive crisis of violence continues to plague gay and bisexual men, revealing deep-rooted prejudice that persists despite legal progress.

In bustling metropolitan centres throughout India, a disturbing narrative of violence against gay and bisexual men is unfolding, challenging the nation’s progressive legal stance on LGBTQIA+ rights and exposing deep-rooted prejudice that continues to threaten the community’s safety and wellbeing.

A ground-breaking new study published in BMC Public Health has drawn attention to the reality of this – that gay and bisexual men are facing systemic discrimination, violence, and marginalisation.

The research, conducted by a collaborative team of academics from prestigious institutions including Indraprastha College for Women, Delhi School of Economics, International Institute for Population Sciences, and Jawaharlal Nehru University, provides a comprehensive and quantitative examination of the violence experienced by men who have sex with men (MSM) across six major Indian cities.

The findings are both shocking and heartbreaking.

Despite the Supreme Court’s landmark 2018 decision to decriminalise homosexuality, the study indicates that legal protection has failed to translate into social acceptance and personal safety.

@barbicancentre 📸  Exiles is a series of images captured by Sunil Gupta to present the complexities faced by gay men at the time.    🎞️  These photographs were staged. The men involved agreed to be featured on the promise that they wouldn’t be shown in India. Homosexuality was only decriminalised in India in 2018.   Throughout the 1980s, artists challenged social spaces across Indian cities, asking if there was a home for marginal groups in these new metropoles. The accompanying text poignantly shares the lived experience of the time, providing insight into their reality.   See these images on show at The Imaginary Institution of India, open now in our Art Gallery 🎟️ #barbican #barbicancentre #artgallery ♬ original sound – Barbican Centre

On average, six out of ten men reported experiencing some form of violence directly linked to their sexual orientation. Young men, particularly those aged between 18 and 24, emerged as the most vulnerable demographic. An alarming 81% of this cohort said they had experienced violence.

The research meticulously unpacks the nuanced layers of violence, categorising it verbally, physically, and sexually, with each form presenting its own traumatic consequences.

Geographical variations in violence patterns add further complexity to the research. Kolkata stands out as a particularly hostile environment, with 80% of those surveyed reporting some form of violence. In contrast, Ahmedabad showed a lower rate of 50%, though this still represents a staggering level of harassment and abuse.

Beyond the statistics are the stories that these findings additionally platform.

A 38-year-old painter from Bengaluru recounts a chilling interaction with his paternal uncle who threatened to kill him if he were his son.

Such accounts reveal the intimate nature of violence, often originating from familial and close social circles, making the trauma even more profound and psychologically devastating.

Many incidents of violence go unreported due to fear of familial intervention or potential police harassment, however, creating a cycle of silence and continued oppression.

Socio-economic factors play a significant role in the vulnerability of MSM.

Men from low-income families, those working in pink-collar jobs (beauticians, sales representatives, and hospitality workers, for example), and those belonging to Other Backward Classes (OBC) communities face disproportionately higher risks of sexual violence.

The researchers also critically examine media representation, arguing that stereotypical portrayals of gay men as effeminate characters primarily used for comic relief have potentially normalised verbal ridicule and contributed to escalating violence, particularly against younger individuals.

@skynews More than 2,000 people have taken to the streets of #NewDelhi to dance, sing and cheer in a #pride #parade held in #India ♬ original sound – Sky News

The study also found that men who are predominantly receptive during intercourse (bottoming) are more exposed to sexual violence, underscoring the intricate power dynamics and systemic vulnerabilities that exist in and outside of the community.

More broadly, the research proves that decriminalisation, while crucial, is merely a first step.

True protection requires a comprehensive social transformation that challenges ingrained prejudice, promotes education, and creates supportive and respectful ecosystems.

The study serves as a powerful call to action for policymakers, activists, and society at large.

It demands a genuine commitment to understanding and respecting sexual diversity and reflects how urgently India needs to dismantle systemic discrimination to bring about a more inclusive, empathetic society that protects the rights and dignity of all its citizens, regardless of sexual orientation.

Accessibility