The would-be 28-year-old rapper’s posthumous release is a tentative, delicate ensemble of rich storytelling, that’s as much about inner peace as it is turmoil.
Mac Miller’s story is one I think about often.
It ends in tragedy and an untimely passing, obviously, but it’s also a shining example of how resilient evolution and talent can reinvent an artist. Within a few short years, a young, white, frat-rap teenager, who seemed unlikely to make a long-lasting dent on hip-hop, became a touchstone of artistic excellence in a cluttered and noisy scene.
And, while Mac was a troubled addict with more demons than he ever deserved, he didn’t let himself become stagnant, always moving from one sound to another. Circles is a testament to all of that hard work, to growth, to open-mindedness, and determination. Mac left us in a very different place creatively to where he started.
This LP, produced mostly by Mac before his passing and finished by Jon Brion, is perhaps his most eclectic and sonically diverse, following on from its predecessor Swimming both thematically and stylistically. Each track here builds on ideas that have come before, offering a project that’s wonderfully familiar and dazzlingly pretty.
That’s not to say it’s treading in the same waters, though, no pun intended. Where Swimming seemed soaked in atmospheric hushes and smothered in echoed reverb, Circles is a more immediate and straight forward listen. From its poignant lead single ‘Good News’ to the smooth, jazzy track ‘Hand Me Downs’, Mac’s lyrics seem to eerily foreshadow his early death, almost as if he knew what was ahead. And, oddly, he seems okay with it. In his own words, ‘there’s more waiting on the other side’.
Many, many moments here will have any Mac Miller fan close to tears. The crooning vocals on ‘Everybody’, coupled with a simple drum and piano score, feel painfully sad to hear given the context. Elsewhere, ‘That’s On Me’ sees Mac take on the blame for all of his personal faults and let downs, never offering solutions to his problems but accepting them all the same.
There’s a range of tones throughout, too, including the electro-funk banger ‘Blue Worlds’, and the fizzing, bouncy ‘Complicated’. Mac’s personality is all still here, as he weaves through complex, heavy introspection and finds peace in himself, expanding upon the funky grooves of Swimming’s lighter moments. Occasionally he deviates away from hip-hop entirely, sounding like a Beatles prodigy on tracks such as ‘Circles’ and ‘Surf’, but never straying too far from the sounds that make him so well loved.
It’s also hard for me to keep an objective perspective when listening to this record. As someone who is deeply attached to his previous album, Circles was always going to be an emotional experience. I’m wholly satisfied with how the project turned out though, and in many ways this is a loving and reassuring closure to a life that should never have been cut so short or so soon.
Circles is a reminder of how fleeting and how fragile our lives are. Mac’s work was a pallet of colour, vibrancy, and disarming openness, and I often had to remind myself that the vocals I was hearing throughout were from someone who was no longer with us.
Given the circumstances, this album comes across almost other worldly, as if an apparition is speaking from somewhere else, trapped inside twelve tracks. This isn’t the case, of course, but there’s something deeply comforting about Circles. It feels like the calm after a storm, a hug after upset, the ray of sunshine that comes after a long, tiring period of greyness. I apologise if that all sounds like wanky nonsense, but it’s easy to get overwhelmed with emotion when talking about this record.
I hope that this is the last album we hear from Mac’s team. I’d hate to see his name go the way of XXXTentacion and Lil Peep, used by record labels for a shameless buck. For now, things seem bright, and Circles should stand as the last and potentially best work from one of hip-hop’s brightest talents. It’s a smile from someone who’s no longer here, and it’s a genuine joy to listen to.
Rest easy, Mac Miller.
4
out of5
'Circles' is a sad, introspective glimpse into the soul.
Mac Miller left us far too soon, but his last project 'Circles' is a wonderful send off for fans, and may give some the closure they've needed for over a year.
I’m Charlie (He/Him), a Remote Writer at Thred. I was previously the Editor at Thred before moving to Bristol in 2024. As a music and gaming enthusiast, I’m a nerd for pop culture. You can find me curating playlists, designing article headline images, and sipping cider on a Thursday. Follow me on Twitter, LinkedIn and drop me some ideas/feedback via email.
Republicans and Democrats, the two largest parties in US politics. In light of some internet debate, let’s analyse whether Jesus Christ would be red or blue.
Jesus Christ the son of God, Prophet Esha, The Messiah. All names for perhaps the most well-known religious figure of the 21st century.
In the bible, he is known to be part of the holy trinity while religions such as Islam view Jesus as a...
The event at Christie’s was intended to demonstrate and test the legitimacy of AI artwork within the high-end auction world. It was met with fierce criticism and enthusiasm from different parties.
An online sale of AI-generated artwork at London’s auction house Christie’s has surpassed its initial earnings estimates by 20%.
The total revenue brought in currently sits at $792,000 USD, with a significant number of new collectors entering the art...
Next month, rapper and musician Offset will perform in Russia, despite his label Universal Music Group having boycotted the country since 2022 due to the invasion of Ukraine.
Offset is gearing up to perform in Russia next month. He is scheduled to appear on stage at MTC Live Hall in Moscow on April 18th 2025.
The news was announced via his Instagram page, where he boasts 25 million followers....
Free and thriving – or just paying more rent? Let’s break down the economics of singledom.
Breathe a sigh of relief, for February is almost over. It’s that special time of year when couples throw cash at overpriced dinners, smugly split the Uber home, and post a well-lit shot of each other on social media.
As for the single population? We’re left to pay the infamous ‘single tax’. But is being...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok