The would-be 28-year-old rapperβs posthumous release is a tentative, delicate ensemble of rich storytelling, thatβs as much about inner peace as it is turmoil.
Mac Millerβs story is one I think about often.
It ends in tragedy and an untimely passing, obviously, but itβs also a shining example of how resilient evolution and talent can reinvent an artist. Within a few short years, a young, white, frat-rap teenager, who seemed unlikely to make a long-lasting dent on hip-hop, became a touchstone of artistic excellence in a cluttered and noisy scene.
And, while Mac was a troubled addict with more demons than he ever deserved, he didnβt let himself become stagnant, always moving from one sound to another. Circles is a testament to all of that hard work, to growth, to open-mindedness, and determination. Mac left us in a very different place creatively to where he started.
This LP, produced mostly by Mac before his passing and finished by Jon Brion, is perhaps his most eclectic and sonically diverse, following on from its predecessor Swimming both thematically and stylistically. Each track here builds on ideas that have come before, offering a project thatβs wonderfully familiar and dazzlingly pretty.
Thatβs not to say itβs treading in the same waters, though, no pun intended. Where Swimming seemed soaked in atmospheric hushes and smothered in echoed reverb, Circles is a more immediate and straight forward listen. From its poignant lead single βGood Newsβ to the smooth, jazzy track βHand Me Downsβ, Macβs lyrics seem to eerily foreshadow his early death, almost as if he knew what was ahead. And, oddly, he seems okay with it. In his own words, βthereβs more waiting on the other sideβ.
Many, many moments here will have any Mac Miller fan close to tears. The crooning vocals on βEverybodyβ, coupled with a simple drum and piano score, feel painfully sad to hear given the context. Elsewhere, βThatβs On Meβ sees Mac take on the blame for all of his personal faults and let downs, never offering solutions to his problems but accepting them all the same.
Thereβs a range of tones throughout, too, including the electro-funk banger βBlue Worldsβ, and the fizzing, bouncy βComplicatedβ. Macβs personality is all still here, as he weaves through complex, heavy introspection and finds peace in himself, expanding upon the funky grooves of Swimmingβs lighter moments. Occasionally he deviates away from hip-hop entirely, sounding like a Beatles prodigy on tracks such as βCirclesβ and βSurfβ, but never straying too far from the sounds that make him so well loved.
Itβs also hard for me to keep an objective perspective when listening to this record. As someone who is deeply attached to his previous album, Circles was always going to be an emotional experience. Iβm wholly satisfied with how the project turned out though, and in many ways this is a loving and reassuring closure to a life that should never have been cut so short or so soon.
Circles is a reminder of how fleeting and how fragile our lives are. Macβs work was a pallet of colour, vibrancy, and disarming openness, and I often had to remind myself that the vocals I was hearing throughout were from someone who was no longer with us.
Given the circumstances, this album comes across almost other worldly, as if an apparition is speaking from somewhere else, trapped inside twelve tracks. This isnβt the case, of course, but thereβs something deeply comforting about Circles. It feels like the calm after a storm, a hug after upset, the ray of sunshine that comes after a long, tiring period of greyness. I apologise if that all sounds like wanky nonsense, but itβs easy to get overwhelmed with emotion when talking about this record.
I hope that this is the last album we hear from Macβs team. Iβd hate to see his name go the way of XXXTentacion and Lil Peep, used by record labels for a shameless buck. For now, things seem bright, and Circles should stand as the last and potentially best work from one of hip-hopβs brightest talents. Itβs a smile from someone whoβs no longer here, and itβs a genuine joy to listen to.
Rest easy, Mac Miller.
4
out of5
'Circles' is a sad, introspective glimpse into the soul.
Mac Miller left us far too soon, but his last project 'Circles' is a wonderful send off for fans, and may give some the closure they've needed for over a year.
Iβm Charlie (He/Him), a Remote Writer at Thred. I was previously the Editor at Thred before moving to Bristol in 2024. As a music and gaming enthusiast, Iβm a nerd for pop culture. You can find me curating playlists, designing article headline images, and sipping cider on a Thursday. Follow me on Twitter, LinkedIn and drop me some ideas/feedback via email.
Rapper and entertainer Snoop Dogg was hit with criticism for performing alongside Nelly, Soulja Boy and others at the first ever βCrypto Ballβ in Washington, D.C.
Snoop Dogg has been hit with a wave of criticism after appearing at the first ever βCrypto Ballβ in Washington D.C last week. The event was a celebration of Trumpβs inauguration.
The rapper was filmed performing his 1990s hit βNuthinβ but a G Thangβ...
With difficulty booking headliners and rising costs, music festivals face their toughest year yet.
Music events are often signposts of our year. Memories with friends, seeing acts youβve only dreamed of witnessing play live. These near-mythic gatherings of collective euphoria are a mainstay of modern culture. But theyβre facing a crossroads.
What used to promise a steady stream of sold-out tickets has become a risky operation littered with bureaucratic obstacles and...
As they did with the Man vs Bear debate, straight men have once again tried to satirise one of womenβs online trends, and itβs only made them look worse.
The #WomenInMaleFields trend that dominated social media not long ago satirises behaviours associated with toxic men and the dating habits they perpetuate.
The general idea is: women overlay a photo/video of themselves with text quoting a heard-before excuse, as if they were...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok