Why did the BBC take down ‘Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone’?

The documentary was immediately praised for offering a unique ‘child’s-eye-view’ of what it is like to live day-today in a war zone, in which many expressed their lack of support and contempt for Hamas. 

Described as ‘harrowing’ and ‘sobering,’ filming through the eyes of children makes total sense, considering that children make up around half of Gaza’s 2.1 million population.

The film was created by an independent company, Hoyo films, and was produced by two BBC employees, Jamie Roberts and Yousef Hammash, who is Palestinian. The pair said they did not originally intend to feature children as the main stars of the film, but that this became an obvious choice when footage began being collected.

Critics are questioning whether the BBC had unknowingly paid members of Hamas to participate in the documentary, which aired for the first time on the 17^th of February.

Learning that the documentary had been pulled from the BBC iPlayer, the International Centre of Justice for Palestinians has urged the broadcaster to ‘stand firm against these attempts to prevent first-hand accounts of life in Gaza from reaching audiences’.

Official documentation of the war, especially from within Gaza, has been left up to journalists in the Gaza Strip and citizens using their smartphone cameras, as Israel banned most news broadcasters from operating within the strip over a year ago.

In a statement, the International Centre of Justice for Palestinians wrote, ‘For some, almost any Palestinian perspective appears to be deemed unacceptable.

‘In this case, objections have been raised because Abdullah’s father holds a government role in Gaza’s Hamas-run administration. However, this does not negate the child’s lived experience or invalidate his testimony.’

A further 500 media figures, including the BBC’s highest-paid star Gary Lineker, Ruth Negga, Juliet Stevenson and Miriam Margolyes, have echoed this statement, calling the documentary ‘an essential piece of journalism’ that offers ‘an all-too-rare perspective on the lived experiences of Palestinians’.

The Guardian has reported that a letter sent to BBC executives Samir Shah, Tim Davie and Charlotte Moore labelled criticism of the documentary as rooted in ‘racist assumptions and weaponisation of identity.’

The letter went further, stating that Hamas’ agriculture minister and father of the teenage narrator is a civil servant concerned with food production, and that ‘broad-brush rhetoric assumes that Palestinians holding administrative roles are inherently complicit in violence – a racist trope that denies individuals their humanity and right to share their lived experiences’.

The Guardian has revealed other signatories of the letter.

They include: ‘the actor Khalid Abdalla, the Bridgerton star India Amarteifio, the novelist Max Porter, the director Ken Loach, the photographer Misan Harriman, the comedian Jen Brister, the presenter Ayo Akinwolere and the writer and actor Asim Chaudhry.’

Having seen the film myself, I’d agree that the film offers not only a devastating insight into what it’s like to grow up in Gaza, but also a humbling glimpse at the positivity and resilience of Palestinian people in the face of, often gruesome, adversity.

Like the 500 media figures who signed the letter to the BBC, I hope the broadcaster can iron out these accusations and make the film easily accessible on its platform once again.