Modern media is struggling to properly represent the LGBTQ+ and LatinX communities in both film and television. In an increasingly diverse society, how is the genuine portrayal of important groups still causing problems for pop culture?
The UK has steadily become more diverse over the last few decades, with less of us identifying as βWhite Britishβ than ever before. As a result, the media and popular culture has had to take steps to become more inclusive and well represented – a trend that extends across western pop culture.
In 2017, for example, Netflix released One Day at a Time, a reimagining of a TV classic that saw a Latin family take centre stage. Black Panther, released in 2018, was made by a Black director and starred a mostly African American cast. It was the second highest grossing film of the year.
Ali Stoker, a wheelchair bound actress, won a Tony award and performed at the ceremony as the character Ado Annie, a normally able-bodied character, from the musical Oklahoma! in 2019.
Transgender representation in popular media has also grown over the past few years thanks to shows such as Shameless and Orange Is the New Black.
While all of this is encouraging progress, is every stride being made authentic and well intentioned?
You may have seen the recent controversy surrounding misrepresentation of the Afro-Latinx community in the new film, In The Heights.
Much excitement surrounded the release of this musical drama which tells the story of a vibrant, tight knit community in Washington Heights, New York. Lin Manuel Miranda, of Hamilton recognition, penned the music and lyrics for the stage version and produced the screen adaptation.
Debate on how certain aspects of the LatinX community are depicted within the film has been steadily bubbling since its release. Critics have remarked that under representation of the Afro-Latinx community in the film shows that colourism remains still a problem within the industry.
Miranda took to Twitter to release a statement explaining how he had initially started writing In the Heights βbecause he didnβt feel seen.β He then went on to apologise to the Afro-Latinx community for failing to adequately represent them in a film that is supposedly celebrating the diversity of Washington Heights.
This begs a larger question of the arts industry as a whole. Even when it makes an active effort to be inclusive, why does it continue to fall short and misrepresent those it aims to champion?
This effort is not enough, however as presence on screen does not necessarily equal representation for the viewer.
While outwardly these figures may appear to tell the tale of increased visibility, Stacie de Armas, senior vice president of diverse consumer insights at Nielsen, magnified the difference between presence and representation.
Speaking to NBC, she says that βwhen you look across the TV landscape, the LGBTQ population looks well represented. But when we look deeper, and at intersectional groups, itβs clear there is a need for greater diversity in LGBTQ representationβ.
βWhite LGBTQ people are most represented on screen, while female LGBTQ people of colour and Latinx LGBTQ people are below parity compared to their population estimatesβ.
The New York Times reported in January of 2021 that across prime-time television there has actually been a decrease in LGBTQ+ representation for the first time in five years.
The article refers to a report by Glaad titled βWhere We Are on TV,β which breaks down how LGBTQ+ characters are affected across primetime, cable, and streaming services. All three outlets show a downturn in representation.
Across Amazon, Hulu, and Netflix the report details that βthere are 95 regular LGBTQ characters on original scripted series, a decrease from last year, as well as 46 LGBTQ recurring characters. This brings the total to 141 LGBTQ characters.β You can view archives of this report back until the 2005-2006 season.
With Gen Z more engaged with media platforms than generations prior, it is vital that they feel represented, whether it be race, gender, or sexuality.
It is time to retire LGBTQ+ tropes in Hollywood. No longer is it appropriate to have a βqueer best friendβ for comic relief.
Just being on the screen doesnβt go as far as needed. Gen Z are looking to the characters in their favourite shows and films for relatability and identity, to feel accepted and actively included in popular culture.
While we may not yet have found the perfect balance, times are progressing.
Despite representation not being the same as presence, it is a possible sign that we are headed towards equal presence in media. As our nation continues to become more diverse so too will the people creating, writing, directing, and casting media.
We must remain positive that diversity in media will continue to reflect the changing creative landscape of modern pop culture.
I join Thred all the way from Northern Ireland, whadda bout ye? Having finished my Masters in English Literature at Ulster University, words have always been a passion of mine. View my LinkedIn or drop me some feedback via email.
The last week of November saw an unexpected champion at the Chinese box office. But beyond the numbers, βHer Storyβ has ignited debates about feminism, representation, and the global lens through which Chinese culture is often viewed.Β
Itβs unusual for a comedy drama, no less a feminist one, to smash records in China's film industry. For a country known for boosting high-budget action and sci-fi movies at the box office,...
Is being explicit how we cope with how out of control things are β and how out of control we feel?
Recently, internationally acclaimed Irish popstar CMAT (Ciara Mary-Alice Thompson) posted an Instagram story responding to someone who criticised how much she swears on social media.
She explained that, sometimes, when thereβs nothing else you can do to relieve yourself from the shittyness of a situation (like an underpaid job that...
While smartphones have granted humans the remarkable ability to stay in touch from anywhere in the world, we need to acknowledge the consequences of never getting a chance to properly 'shut off'.Β
Throughout history, no other group of human beings have lived the way we do, that is, completely immersed in and unable to escape a culture of being βalways onβ and βavailableβ.
The seamless connectivity offered by modern technology...
When culture, tradition, and religion meet
From October 13th to December 12th, the streets of Nuevo Leon, Mexico are painted with colors, street vendors, and food stalls in preparation for the hundreds of pilgrimages arriving at the sanctuary of the Virgin of Guadalupe.
When we think of Mexican celebrations, what comes to mind is usually the Day of the Dead, a celebration characterized by the fact that anyone can celebrate it,...
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok
0 comments
