Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

The power of swearing in positions of powerlessness

Is being explicit how we cope with how out of control things are – and how out of control we feel?

Recently, internationally acclaimed Irish popstar CMAT (Ciara Mary-Alice Thompson) posted an Instagram story responding to someone who criticised how much she swears on social media.

She explained that, sometimes, when there’s nothing else you can do to relieve yourself from the shittyness of a situation (like an underpaid job that wears you out and forces you to spend time with people that treat you badly) going home to complain about it is the only outlet available – that there’s power in swearing as a dramatic form of expression and communication.

‘You say those things and you do those things because you have no power in that situation,’ she said. ‘You can’t quit that job. You can’t fucking leave that life. All you can do is express yourself and express the severity of your emotions and I think swearing is a great way to do that.’

This emphasises the use of swearing as a proletarian tool, an individual yet universal – and deeply ubiquitous – act of resistance against mass socio-political exploitation and oppression.

The retail assistant scenario is a good one, as are any examples of working in customer-facing roles, which notoriously see minimum-wage workers maltreated by intolerably rude customers who they’re forced to be polite towards.

@cmatbaby silly bitches unite !! European tour start in paris on monday !! #livemusic #glastonbury ♬ I Don’t Really Care for You – CMAT

Contrastingly, there actually tends to be more acceptance towards the use of profanities within more manual (and male dominated) labour fields.

You’re having to work long shifts and probably even do over-time just to make ends meet. You’re also having to answer to a higher-paid boss who seems to work less than you do, and doesn’t understand how to do your job. Yeah… when you put it like that… it’s a fucking shitshow.

As Melissa Mohr writes in Holy Sh*t: A Brief History of Swearing, soldiers during the first world war used ‘fucking’ so frequently that it began to function simply as a prefix for whatever noun would succeed it.

And as Ciara posits: when you’re powerless in ‘the face of dark times, especially in the current political climate,’ swearing is an outlet when you can’t do anything else. It’s all relative.

Despite the occasional stigma that clings to certain obscenities, the tendency to include curse words such as ‘fuck’ and ‘shit’ in our vocabulary has recently been said to demonstrate a wider command of language, to emphasise a point in a conversational setting, or to build social bonds.

@susiedent Word of the Day! #lalochezia #wordoftheday #susiedent #countdown #foryoupage ♬ original sound – Susie Dent

What’s more, the reclamation of swearing from traditionally male, working-class spaces by people like Ciara – who occupies a role in society as both a woman and member of the queer community –  serves as evidence of the pervasive empowerment and solidarity across intersectional cultural spaces that the use of profanities evokes.

For instance, ‘bitch’ has become a term of endearment for many, and ‘serving cunt’ is a popular phrase employed in queer communities and within drag culture to mean that someone is displaying confident characteristics in a boisterous, usually sassy or ‘fierce’ way.

Far from the banning of texts like D.H.Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover for its use of the c-word, so universal have phrases like this become in internet vernacular that everyone, from Beyoncé, to Bimini Bon Boulash (@biminibabes), to Franz Kafka are either using, or indeed serving, them.

However, as Christian Ilbury points out in his article for The Conversation, it’s also important not to overlook the origins of this sort of language associated with drag culture originally from African American Vernacular English (AAVE).

More specifically, this language originated in the LGBTQ+ subculture formed by African American and Latino people in New York City in the 1980s who participated in ‘ball culture,’ which involves participants ‘walking’ to compete for prizes at events known as balls.

@tiktok ever wondered what ballroom culture is like? this is where elegance meets fierce artistry and unapologetic self-expression. ballroom culture transforms spaces into a vibrant and inclusive celebration of identity and community. safe to say the creators at the #TikTokCreatorBall definitely showed up ready to GIVE 💃🏳️‍🌈 #PrideMonth #BallroomScene #LGBTQ #VogueDance #YouBelongHere #ForYourPride ♬ original sound – TikTok

The use of phrases like this can be problematic because the appropriation of certain terms from the culture of one ethnic minority (African American) by another oppressed group (gay men), lies in part on the racial imagining of the ‘sassy black woman’ to pave the way for what Ilbury terms the ‘sassy queen.’

However, I also think it’s important to consider both the context and the intent.

Ilbury analyses certain phrases such as ‘work dat pole gurl’ and ‘y’all mad at hunty’ which, when used by British Gay men, potentially reify ‘black women as vivacious, outspoken, and lively.’

On the flipside, perhaps we can see swearing – especially by another oppressed group of people – as a unifying tool in the face of multiple kinds of oppression rather than viewing the appropriation of certain terms, as Ilbury does, in a way which could perpetuate further divisions based upon stereotypes.

Then we can empathise with one another and persevere together in the ongoing struggle against exploitative fucking capitalism.

Accessibility