Menu Menu
[gtranslate]

2023โ€™s Oscar nominations fail to make meaningful progress

No Black actors were nominated for leading categories this year. Once again, they deserved better.ย 

When the 2022 Oscar nominations were announced, Black actors and directors ruled the roost. It was a comforting โ€“ and deserved โ€“ย outcome after years of โ€˜#oscarssowhiteโ€™ protest, a nod to the academyโ€™s consistent failings in diversity and inclusion.

But this year, it seems that this positive shift was only a phase. Despite a slew of Black performers and filmmakers getting Oscar nods in 2023, there have been no Black individuals nominated in leading categories.

Amongst the biggest snubs were Viola Davis โ€“ whose leading role in Woman King was expected to pick up a Lead Actress nomination โ€“ and Danielle Deadwylerโ€™s breakthrough role in โ€˜Tillโ€™.

Despite a nomination for Angela Bassett in Actress in Supporting Role, blockbuster hit Black Panther went unrecognised for Best Picture.

Along with a lack of Black actors in leading categories, this yearโ€™s Oscars had another notable absence; women directors. And specifically Black women.

Sarah Polley (dir. โ€˜Women Talkingโ€™), Gina Prince-Bythewood (dir. โ€˜The Woman Kingโ€™), Maria Schrader (dir. โ€˜She Said), and Charlotte Wells (dir. โ€˜Aftersunโ€™) were all frontrunners in the best director line-up. Yet not one received a nomination.

But it isnโ€™t all doom and gloom. 2023 has been an incredible year for Asian-American representation, with โ€˜Everything Everywhere All at Onceโ€™ receiving 11 nominations. This includes Michelle Yeohโ€™s nod for Best Actress in a Leading Role.

In fact, โ€˜Everything Everywhereโ€™ has led the pack of this yearโ€™s nominations, and done so with an almost entirely Asian-American main cast.

But despite their successes, Black actors and directors have โ€“ once again โ€“ย been given the short end of the stick.

Following the nominations, Women in Film โ€“ย a Los Angeles-based organisation supporting female representation in the industry โ€“ called out the Academy for omitting women filmmakers.

โ€˜Once again, Academy voters have shown that they donโ€™t value womenโ€™s voices, shutting us out of the Best Director nominationsโ€™.

Some have noted, however, that this support hasnโ€™t โ€“ย and wouldnโ€™t โ€“ be afforded to Black stars in the same way.

โ€˜This allyship and amplification are rarely extended to racialised, queer and disabled people and often comes at their expense [sic]โ€™ said producer and diversity advocate Prasanna Ranganathan.ย 

In response to this yearโ€™s nominations, netizens have resurrected the โ€˜#oscarssowhiteโ€™ hashtag on twitter.

โ€˜Twice as hard, half as far. The #oscarssowhite playing out like always for Danielle and Violaโ€™, tweeted music critic Britt Julious.

The Academy has undoubtedly made important changes to its diversity. Since 2012, when The Times found nearly 94% of Oscar voters to be Caucasian, and 77% to be male, structural shifts have seen breakthrough success for Black actors and filmmakers. From Barry Jenkinsโ€™ โ€˜Moonlightโ€™ winning Best Picture in 2017, to Will Smith winning Best Actor last year.

But 2023 proves these changes may only be cosmetic.

If the Academyโ€™s habit of snubbing Black stars canโ€™t be consistently broken, then one is left to believe that their recognition of non-White individuals is mere tokenism. And that gives sway to the mounting belief that the Oscarsโ€™ โ€˜final wordโ€™ has little meaning at all.

Accessibility