Menu Menu

UNESCO calls for a global tech detox in schools

The use of technology in schools has become increasingly prevalent in the past few decades. UNESCOโ€™s new report sheds light on the consequences of this reliance.

Over the past few decades, technology has become so pervasive that itโ€™s hard to imagine a world without it. It has allowed interconnectivity throughout the world whilst making day-to-day activities much easier.

The rise of digital learning is transforming the way students learn as they use technology to access information and complete coursework โ€“ or to scroll through TikTok and play games.

This easy accessibility to the digital world has engrossed young people. However, this widespread use of technology has sparked discussions about its potential consequences, prompting calls for a balance between the good and the bad.

In an effort to settle this debate, UNESCOโ€™s recent report called for the usage of technology in schools to be heavily regulated; aiming to address the rising dependency on digital tools as the primary means of educating children.

The organisationโ€™s Director-General Audrey Azoulay noted that the digital revolution had the capability to transform learning experiences, but it could not be at the cost of the well-being of students and teachers.

Manos Antoninis, the director in charge of the report, argued that children should be taught to use technology in a balanced way. He believed it should be used to support classroom activities and warned against the dangers of it superseding human interactions in teaching and learning.

UNESCO did recognize the potential of technological assistance to open up new opportunities for disabled learners. In particular, this could be through accessing information and resources that would not be otherwise available to them or aiding them to communicate with their peers.

The report also addressed the impact of how meaningful connectivity through technology is becoming synonymous with the right to education, but access to it remains uneven worldwide. A significant number of primary and secondary schools globally lack internet connection, despite 85% of countries having policies to enhance connectivity.

A potential regulation in the usage of technology in schools addresses the inequalities and disparities in access to educational technology, particularly for students from a lower socio-economic background. While technology can offer valuable learning opportunities and support, it can also be a source of exclusion for disadvantaged learners.

Not all students have equal access to technology and reliable internet connectivity, which can lead to a digital divide and hinder their ability to fully participate in educational opportunities.

In addition, the unrestricted use of devices such as smartphones in schools has been associated with an increase in cyberbullying and social pressures among students. The anonymity and ease of communication provided by smartphones can facilitate harmful online behavior, including cyberbullying and the spread of rumors.

Such negative interactions can have severe consequences on students’ mental health and well-being, leading to feelings of anxiety, stress, and isolation.

The evolution of technology also strains education systems and their ability to adapt. UNESCO argues that digital literacy and critical thinking are increasingly important, particularly with the growth of generative AI. The report shows that 54% of countries surveyed have outlined their wish to develop those skills, but only 11 out of 51 governments surveyed have included them in their curriculums.

Antoninis pointed out that only half of the countries currently have standards for developing educatorsโ€™ ICT skills and even fewer have teachers’ training programs covering cybersecurity.

In recent years, there has been a growing number of studies that suggest that using phones can have a negative impact on the academic performance of students. Those who use their phones for non-education purposes during classes typically take lower-quality notes, retain less information, and do worse on tests.

When it came to laptops, students who used them in classes were more likely to have lower grades than students who did not. At the same time, completely banning laptops led to lower quality of written work, lower attendance, and lower exam scores, further proving that the debate on technology in schools is not absolute to any side.

Globally, an estimated 1 in 7 countries have banned phones in schools, the most recent being the Netherlands. In France, since 2010, the use of the device during school hours has been prohibited in order to โ€œprovide students with an environment that fosters attention, concentration and reflection.โ€

In addition, research by LSE in 2015 revealed that the ban resulted in higher academic performance, especially among low-performing students. Addressing the well-being of students, similar studies performed in Norway and Spain indicated a decrease in bullying incidences following the regulations of phones.

Ultimately, UNESCOโ€™s report does not suggest a complete ban on technology in schools but rather for governments to prioritize evidence-based approaches that ensure a healthy balance between digital tools and face-to-face interaction with their peers.

Accessibility