Menu Menu

It’s time to take the insect apocalypse more seriously

Scientists have been shouting about the dire consequences of plummeting insect populations for years, and it’s time we paid attention.

The first Global Scientific Review of insect populations came out in 2019, and it served to emphasise something that the entomological community was already well aware of: the world’s insects are hurtling towards extinction. The report went so far as to call the steep reduction an ‘extinction event’, stating that it would easily lead to a ‘catastrophic collapse of nature’s ecosystems’.

Almost a year has passed, and the situation is only growing worse. The analysis shows that more than 40% of insect species are declining, and a third are endangered. Their rate of extinction is eight times faster (yes eight) than mammals, birds, and reptiles. The total mass of insects on Earth is falling by approximately 2.5% a year.

The consequences of this decimation are far reaching. It doesn’t just mean an empty honey jar. Insects pollinate plants, which we eat. They get eaten by mammals, which we eat. They are an integral and irreplaceable facet of the biosphere. When asked to imagine what would happen is insects were to disappear completely, scientists tend to find words like ‘chaos, collapse, Armageddon’ and ‘apocalypse’.

And the cause of all this? You guessed it. Us.

 

How bad actually is it?

Bad. The current worldwide loss of biodiversity is popularly known as the sixth extinction: the sixth time in world history that a large number of species have disappeared in unusually rapid succession, caused this time not by asteroids or ice ages but by humans. When we think about losing biodiversity, we tend to think of the last northern white rhinos protected by armed guards, or of polar bears dwindling on ice caps. Extinction is an emotive tragedy, and it’s one we all understand – the word brings up a feeling of permanence.

We’ve named and described a million species of insects, a stupefying array of gnats and firebrats and froghoppers (yes you can google all of these) and other families of bug that even experts can’t name. There are 12,000 types of ant, 20,000 varieties of bee, and almost 400,000 species of beetle. A bit of healthy soil, a foot square, and two inches deep might easily be home to 200 different species of mites, each with a subtly different job to do. And yet entomologists estimate that all this amazing, absurd, and understudied variety represents perhaps only 20% of the actual diversity of insects on our planet – that there are millions of insect species that entirely unknown to science.

That’s what makes the 2.5% rate of annual loss over the past 25-30 so shocking. As ecologist Sánchez-Bayo told the Guardian in an interview, ‘it is very rapid. In 10 years you will have a quarter less [insects], in 50 years only half left and in 100 years you will have none.’

Last year’s report selected the 72 best studies on insect decline to assess the overall trends, finding that butterflies and moths are among the worst hit. The number of butterfly species in England fell by 58% between 2000 and 2009. Bees have also been seriously affected, with only half of the bumblebee species found in the US in 1949 being present in 2013. The number of honeybee colonies in the US was six million in 1974, but it is now under three million.

A small number of extremely adaptable species, like the West African bee, are increasing in number, but not nearly enough to offset the big losses. The speed and scale of loss has been stunning even to entomologists who were already anxious about bees and fireflies, or the increased cleanliness of car windshields the world over.

What are the consequences?

‘There is reason to worry,’ says Francisco Sánchez-Bayo, a researcher at the University of Sydney in Australia, in the report. ‘If we don’t stop it, entire ecosystems will collapse due to starvation.’

Insects serve as the base of the ecological food pyramid, eaten by everything from birds to small mammals to fish. If they decline, it stands to reason everything else will as well.

They also provide several other invaluable and underappreciated services to humanity. About three fourths of all flowering plants are pollinated by insects, as well as the crops that produce over one third of the world’s food supply. Trillions of bugs flitting from flower to flower pollinate some three-quarters of our food crops, a service worth as much as $500 billion every year.

By eating and being eaten, insects turn plants into protein and power the growth of all the uncountable species — including freshwater fish and a majority of birds — that rely on them for food, not to mention all the creatures that eat those creatures. No insects equals no food. Which equals no people. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist.

Another service insects provide behind the scenes? Waste disposal and nutrient cycling. Without insects like dung beetles and other decomposers breaking down and removing animal and plant waste, our surroundings would be less than pleasant, to say the least.

Basically, without insects we’d live in a barren world. Ecosystems would collapse, nature overall would wither and decay, and there would be a starvation crisis unlike anything we’ve seen before.

The kicker? Insects don’t even need to go completely extinct for this to occur. Scientists have begun to talk about what’s known as ‘functional extinction’, as opposed to numeric extinction. Functionally extinct animals and plants are still present but no longer prevalent enough to affect how an ecosystem works. You can phrase this as the eradication not of a species, but of all its former interactions with its environment – an extinction of pollination and seed dispersal and predation, which can be devastating even if some individuals still persist. The more interactions are lost, the more disordered the ecosystem becomes.

A 2013 paper in the Nature magazine, which modelled both natural and computer-generated food webs, suggested that a loss of even 30% of a species’ abundance can be so destabilising that other species start going fully, numerically extinct. In some areas such an affect is already being felt. In Puerto Rico, for example, upwards of 24 species of frog have gone extinct since 1996 due to a loss in their food supply.

It’s easy to see how this domino effect could lead to a human food crisis sooner rather than later.

 

What can we do about it?

There are two main causes for this rapid decline in insects: industrialisation, and global warming.

Like every species on earth, insects are reacting to the transformation of a world under climate change. They’re also contending with the widespread conversion, via urbanisation, agricultural intensification and the general conversion of natural spaces into human ones. There are now fewer and fewer resources ‘left over’ for nonhuman creatures to live on, and what resources do remain are often contaminated.

The thing that could ultimately help insect populations more than anything else would be to address climate change. Of course, this is a mammoth task that in an ideal world would be first on every political agenda globally.

Beyond that, conservation and management is crucial. New methods of farming that require less pesticides, or simply the creation of more ecologically friendly and less toxic pesticides, will have a dramatic impact on helping humans and insects coexist.

The fact of the matter is, at present we simply don’t have enough information on the issue. Not enough research has been done as insect degradation isn’t the jazziest talking point for politicians, or even activists, meaning that research is severely underfunded. It’s only when scientific bodies are given the resources to properly analyse and measure the specific ecological influences on various insect species that systems can be put in place. It’s only when we truly understand the nuances of the various impacts that we can start to repair.

It’s certainly not an easy fix. But becoming aware of the issue as future policy makers is surely the first step. If the issue is taken seriously by the next generation of government and business leaders, then a balanced ecosystem may still be within our grasp.

So, if you see a dehydrated bee, give it some sugar water will you?

Accessibility