Menu Menu

The rising trend of Instagram therapists

Internet culture is again turning a once intimately personal contract public; that between a person and their therapist.

Scrolling through Lisa Olivera’s Instagram feed (@lisaoliveratherapy) you get the distinct feeling that 2019 has leaped out of the screen and punched you in the face. Or, rather, in this generation of non-violent protest, you get the distinct feeling that 2019 has leaned in and kissed you lightly on the forehead.

View this post on Instagram

A reminder for all of us, myself included: We can never fully live as a pretend version of ourselves. Removing the mask and not knowing what’s left can be grief-inducing. And… the grief in confronting the process of reconnecting with your true, whole self leads us to the truth in a way keeping the mask on never will. Keep unlayering. Keep unraveling. Keep seeking. Keep looking. Keep sifting through. Keep digging. Keep inquiring. Keep observing. Keep questioning. Keep going. And then, practice trusting what you find. Wearing the mask and removing the mask are both painful and challenging processes, but only one can bring us freedom. Your true self is waiting for you to remove the mask and remember. 💫

A post shared by Lisa Olivera (@lisaoliveratherapy) on

A desert palette of black, mauve and slate mix with beautiful imagery of hands grasping poppies and wild grass greets you. The artistic flourishes are met with stark white sans sherif and graphs, to remind you that the art of feeling well is also serious business. The feed consists largely of quotes and lists that essentially boil down to wellness ‘cheat sheets’: how to connect with yourself, to ‘say yes to yourself’, and how to heal from heartache.

It’s pretty, it’s thoughtful, and it’s really, really #woke.

These colours and icons are trademarks of influence in the age of peak wellness that we currently live in, and their appearance on Instagram can often concoct images of Gwyneth Paltrow and other glammed up nonexperts trying to sell you marble things to put various places for no discernible reason.

Lisa Olivera is no such quack (sorry Gwen but that spade you’ve got is a spade). She’s a licensed marriage and family therapist with a private practice in California. And, as well as spending hours a week conducting expensive private sessions, she’s one of dozens of councillors who’ve decided to democratise a portion of their time and therapist’s wisdom on Instagram, for all to enjoy.

Social media has unexpectedly become one of the most influential ways Gen Z and wellness advocates can normalise discussions of mental health. A once stigmatised topic, the soaring rates of depression and anxiety among young people has necessitated discourse on the topic like never before. Whilst some clever marketing experts have been capitalising on the so-called ‘therapy generation’, the involvement of real therapists on a social media platform poses a host of potential new benefits, and risks.

 

How it could be game changing

Despite the many calls from young people to alter a prohibitive system, a lot of mental health care remains expensive and moderately stigmatised (particularly in the US). According to The New York Times, of the nearly two in five young people who experienced mental health issues in 2017, less than half received any kind of professional help. This gap in supply and demand is an issue that Insta therapists wish to address.

View this post on Instagram

As children, we depend on our parents or caregivers in a unique way. Our livelihood is in their hands. What we want more than anything is to be seen, heard + loved by them. Yet, because of their own unresolved trauma, few of us get this experience. So we unconsciously learn to betray ourselves to receive love. We perform. We achieve. We rebel. We become who we believe we need to be to be seen. Then, in adulthood we do this in every relationship we have. Our self worth is so low because we don’t trust ourselves with our own word. To heal self betrayal, we need to start to make + keep promises to ourselves. We need to have boundaries. Even if that means being misunderstood: and you will be misunderstood. It’s part of the process. Surrender to it. The most important relationship you’ll ever have is the relationship with yourself. Do the work to trust your own word. As your self worth improves, so does every relationship you have #selfhealers

A post shared by Dr. Nicole LePera (@the.holistic.psychologist) on

Andrea Glik is a New York based psychotherapist who started her own Insta, @somaticwitch, after realising that she had access to resources that shouldn’t be proprietary to only those who could afford therapy (as she tells Man Repeller here).

She believed the sort of thing that’s par for the course for every therapist shouldn’t be privileged information. It’s often vital things about our minds and bodies that we’re completely in the dark about, or simply aren’t usually given the space to think about. Take this post about how to recognise the difference between conditioning and neuroplasticity for example:

View this post on Instagram

Ok first off because this part confused me at first: CONDITIONING CAN BE POSITIVE OR IT CAN BE UNHELPFUL/VIOLENT etc. ✨ But for the purpose of this post, let’s focus on the conditioning we learned from caregivers or society that we want to let go of and unlearn. People pleasing. White Supremacy (note: for white folks this work is NEVER OVER). Internalized homo/transphobia. Never feeling good enough. Feeling like we have to be scary/alone/guarded to be safe. ✨ Neuroplasticity offers us the chance to change some of these conditioned thought and belief patterns. ✨ This can be literally unlearning and relearning through education, especially around isms, or books to better understand yourself like In my highlights (knowledge is power is healing). ✨ This can be new experiences, repeated until we believe it’s ok to make everyone happy or we deserve love (setting a boundary, making your end, holding your heart and breathing, only dating people who understand trauma).

A post shared by Andrea Glik, LMSW she/her (@somaticwitch) on

It’s a radical shift for a medium that was created as a way for friends to share picture of their last breakfast, but Insta therapists are proving increasingly popular. Lisa Olivera boasts over 200k followers, whilst others like Dr. Nicole LePera (the.holistic.psychologist) have over 700k.

The insta therapists openly recognise that sharing generalised insights and advice is a far cry from ‘personalised’ therapy. Most refrain from giving followers individual advice, as the platform is not confidential and because, well, there are only so many hours in the day.

But in the manner they exist now it’s clear that these accounts can be used as a gateway to a more nuanced relationship with the self, reminding people as they scroll through their feeds to pay closer attention to themselves – something that it’s easy to forget to do in an age of over-stimulation.

How it could be risky

Whilst Insta therapy boasts the benefit of being almost totally free (flagging up the ‘ability to own a smartphone’ privilege here), and in the hands of a skilled therapist and thoughtful user could yield a more astute approach to mindfulness, it can also be likened to the junk food of therapy. It’s addictive, and ultimately not enough to sustain you.

For starters, to receive the benefits of this Instagram therapy, you must first spend more time on Instagram. This creates something of a paradox when you consider the many studies that have clearly outlined that social media is a negative influence on our mental health when consumed in large quantities.

Facebook and Instagram are correlated with dissatisfaction with body image, fad dieting, substance abuse, and self-harm ideation. And it’s hard to believe that people would be able to avoid these negative facets of the platform in favour of a solely therapeutic experience. But even if you do, you’d still be committing to spending more time with your screen, as opposed to finding rest and relationships in your natural environment.

Moreover, Insta therapy posts have both the benefit and the drawback of being fairly broad. Clearly, to cater for expanding audiences, Insta therapists can’t take the approach of the ‘typical’ psychologist and tailor their treatment to the individual.

Now, whilst there’s no particular problem with nonspecific advice, sometimes the posts you see on these accounts can lean towards the overly ideological, or worse, the superficial. I’m sure the extremely opinionated Insta therapist @thefatsextherapist has done a lot of inner development to get to her point of view, but what about people who are still working to get there?

 

View this post on Instagram

 

if you’re like me you grew up with caregivers who were convinced it would be next to impossible to have a fulfilled life with abundance and joy while also being fat. well i’m here to tell you they were wrong . and the most important thing to help me see it was untrue was the existence of fat happy role models. that doesn’t mean these role models weren’t allowed to be anything other than happy, but seeing fat people with fat arms and double chins and overhanging bellies offered me a new, radical possibility model. it offered me one that included an image of my own body . to have been able to grow into the person i am today i needed the photos and writings of: @roxanegay74 @bitchesgottaeat @chairbreaker @thelindywest @thesamhita @virgietovar @lesley.was.here (among many others, these are just a few off the top of my head) . and this is a journey i’ve been on since 2011. so pls know this will take time ❤️ give yourself that space to grow. and we’ve come a long way from 2011. so pls share who you follow in the comments below 🥰 we are all looking for new possibility models who allow us to be better integrated versions of our whole selves 😘 sometimes we can only be what we see/envision/imagine 🔮

A post shared by Sonalee (sun-NAH-lee) (@thefatsextherapist) on

The danger is that authoritative pronouncements on complex issues can represent a shortcut, or ‘psycho-spiritual bypass’, around the harder work of thinking, feeling, and growing that’s part of actual therapy.

Moreover, whilst most people intuitively know the differences between Insta therapy and private therapy, there’s always the risk that people with serious issues may reach out to these accounts. What does the Insta-therapist do with a truly concerning comment or DM? Instagram currently has no guidelines or procedure were such an event to occur.

 

To sum up

Instagram therapy is the Wild West of psychology. It’s uncharted territory. There already seem to be some ‘winners’ from the trend – therapists who’ve expanded their practices online to the tune of tens of thousands of followers, and even book deals.

It’s very possible that good may come from the new frontier, with people gaining access to valuable information and alternative types of thinking who might otherwise be in the dark. However, it certainly can’t hold a candle to the kind of intimate relationship one can form with a psychologist in person.

In my opinion, spending less time on social media, and more time with friends, reading books, or at culture festivals will probably yield better resulted for your personal growth. And, of course, finding a therapist who resonates with you as an individual either through private practice or through an online service (often free!) is potentially life changing, and should definitely be the first port of call for anyone truly in need of help.

But what do I know, I’m no therapist.

Accessibility