Menu Menu

Petition calls for Sydney NYE fireworks to be cancelled during deadly fires

More than a quarter of million people have signed a petition calling for Sydney’s New Year’s Eve fireworks to be cancelled and the money spent on fighting fires, but is this really directing people’s anger in the right way?

Every December above the Sydney harbour bridge, one of the world’s more ostentatious fireworks displays rings in the new year to the delight and congestion of thousands of revellers. The Sydney fireworks are widely televised as a defining moment in the national calendar, often beamed overseas as one of the first regional dominos to fall into the new calendar.

Some AUD $5.8m ($4m USD; £3m) was reportedly spent on the fireworks last year, with a similar amount on the bill for this year’s festivities. But some Sydneysiders don’t want it.

More than 250,000 people have signed an online petition asking for the show to be cancelled, stating that the money should be spent on supplementing firefighting efforts. The petition website says that the smoke from the fireworks ‘may traumatise some people’ who are dealing with ‘enough smoke in the air.’

Sydney’s lord mayor Clover Moore has weighed in, commenting on the petition site that whilst her ‘deepest sympathies’ are with those effected by the blazes, the majority of the fireworks budget has already been spent. She has pointed out that the infamous event generates around AUD $130m for the local economy, which many Sydneysiders and business owners rely on. ‘… we can’t cancel the fireworks and even if we could, doing so would have little practical benefit’ she concludes.

As far as calling the petition too little too late, she’s got a point. At this stage, cancelling the fireworks would save little money and would mostly serve to put thousands of people out of deposits for hotels and restaurants. By way of compensating the clearly irate petitioners, Moore has committed to ‘harnessing the enormous power of the event’ to raise more money for the Australian Red Cross Disaster Relief and Recovery Fund.

The petition is a misguided attempt to divert what is a very legitimate frustration on the part of Australian residents at the blatant mismanagement of the ecological crisis that’s so far cost eight human lives (including two volunteer firefighters), the lives of hundreds of millions native animals, and thousands of homes.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison tragically had to cut his Christmas holiday to Hawaii short this December to manage the historic heatwave that hit the country that same month, adding literal fuel to the fires that have been ravaging NSW since September. Many citizens have protested that the mistimed vacation came after a solid two months of inaction from Morrison, with Twitter users rightfully pointing out that no other world leader in recent memory has had the indecency to take a break whilst their nation was in crisis.

Morrison has called the fires a ‘national disaster’ but that’s about as far as he’s gone to acknowledging the severity of the disaster. The ‘thoughts and prayers’ he’s typically been sending bushfire victims have not extended to an increased budget for fighting the fires, or proper compensation for the volunteer firefighters tackling the blazes, who make up 90% of the current firefighting force and are as yet unpaid.

According to Morrison, existing resource were doing fine to tackle the 3 million hectares currently on fire (for reference, the 2018 California wildfires consumed 1.8 million hectares, and the Amazon fires burned through an estimated 900,000 hectares) and that volunteers ‘want to be there’. Seems legit.

The most alarming aspect of Australian government’s response to the fires, however, is their inability to acknowledge the connection between the warming climate, and their own continued support of coal powered energy. Australia has one of the highest per capita greenhouse gas emission rates globally and is one of the worlds biggest exporters of coal. The 2020 Climate Change Performance Index ranked Australia last out of 57 countries for its climate policy, stating that it’s regressed under Morrison’s government.

The group Emergency Leaders for Climate Action, made up of former fire chiefs and emergency leaders, has accused the government of being ‘missing in action’ on climate action and ignoring calls for a crisis summit. By Morrison continues to claim that reigning in the country’s emissions would be merely ‘a drop in the ocean’ compared to the impact of superpowers like China and the US. Evidently, that that drop isn’t worth contributing to potentially help prevent Australia’s fire season worsening year on year until the country becomes virtually uninhabitable.

Refinery29 journalist Katie Leaver, currently residing in Sydney, observes that whilst ‘this is a country that knows the heat… this kind of heat is unnatural. It’s cruel and it’s frightening. It’s only the beginning of summer… and it might get worse – much worse.’ As climate scientists have attested, if the world doesn’t keep warming down to below 2 degrees Celsius by 2030 worse is the only direction we’re likely to go.

But, for now, Australians can at least take comfort in the fact that ScoMo has officially now returned home from his holiday, stating ‘I deeply regret any offence caused to any of the many Australians affected by the terrible bushfires by my taking leave with family at this time.’

Now Scott can watch with the rest of Sydney as his hopes and dreams of a sunburnt country go up in smoke. And I’m not just talking about the December 31st fireworks.

Accessibility